Tag: Psychology

  • Anima on the wheel – Female Archetypes of Toni Wolff

    Anima on the wheel – Female Archetypes of Toni Wolff

    Not only an essay

    Let’s say this is not only an essay of Female Archetypes, but also a semi-fictional story. I was very pleased, that good friend of mine, who happens to be a catholic monk and Jungian psychoanalyst, accepted to be the god-father of my son. Since he lives somewhat remote on the country side – you guessed it, his home is a monastery – I picked him up on the day of the confirmation. I wanted also to show my appreciation. During the car ride, we discussed the contribution of women in psychoanalytic realm particularly C.G. Jung and women. I tested a little bit my upcoming article regarding Sabina Spielrein, and from there the conversation wandered to the subject Toni Wolff and Female Archetypes.  We agreed, that she had written the most concise essay on the Anima,  besides the two essays Emma Jung’s  “Animus and Anima”, a work, he said, still widely used by psychoanalysts.  C.G. Jung developed the idea of the Anima and Animus from his analytical practice and from examining his own psychology. Jung recognized, that there is an inferior feminine orientation in the male psyche which he named the Anima, from the Latin word for spirit, and an inferior masculine orientation in the female psyche which he called the Animus.

    Five Key Women

    Female Archetypes
    The female Vampire

    Beside Jungs’s circle of women analysts and writers, like Jolande Jacobi, Aniela Jaffe, and Marie Louise Von Franz, five key women played an important role in Jung’s life and the generation of his theory. They are Jung’s mother, his cousin Hélène Preiswerk (the first patient), Sabina Spielrein (the first patient in analysis), Emma Jung (his wife) and Toni Wolff his long-time collaborator (and many say almost minor wife). They were Medial Woman deeply embedded in Jung’s emotional life. By inductive intuition, he moved from specific observations to broader generalizations and theories. Jung’s women shaped his ideas by Memories, Dreams and Reflections, particularly Sabina Spielrein, his prototype of an Anima. Revelation of their psyches (Sabina and Toni began as patients), and Jung’s own during the crisis years gave way to The Red Book and theory. What crucially distinguishes Jung from much of the psychiatric practice surrounding him (especially Freud) was his refusal to regard spontaneous unconscious phenomena as pathological. Men by nature are more normally  dualistic predisposed  (formative ability and instinctive impulsiveness), thus their cultural achievements more determined by the intellect or spirit. There conscious attitude and coping with the reality are therefore usually based on the most differentiated function.  However, Jung certainly worked empiric with two functions,  “thinking”  and intuition.

    Archetypes according to Tony Wolff

    According to Toni Wolff, women are inherently more conditioned by their soul, so her spirit and sexuality is rooted in the he psychical dimension. Their consciousness is therefore more comprehensive and holistic, but less defined.

    AnimaToniWolf
    AnimaToniWolf

    Toni Wolff structured the Anima in an interesting quadruple of four basic archetypes. She said the names are not of much importance, but one could describe them as the mental forms of Mother (and wife), the Hetaira (companion, friend), the Amazon and the Medial Woman. They have in common with the psychological function types, that their axes are opposite (i.e, personal or impersonal relation), that means usually a form is the predominant, a second can join it, the third and fourth first are unconscious, and only later in of life one can made aware of and integrated with difficulty. In this respect, all four forms are detectable through the cultural history, and likely to be female archetypal structures. They are aspects of the male Anima and the structure scheme would be the following:

    • The Mother archetype represents the woman’s natural capacity and numinous power to conceive, give birth, sustain, and renew life  charitable by motherly cherishing, nursing, helping and teaching. Her instinct reacts to all in man, for which must cared for or what needs protection and development.
    • The  Amazon archetype is independent and self-contained in a positive sense and highly capable of making her way in the world. Amazon represents the adventurous, often traveling in the direct sense of the word, but also into the territory traditionally occupied by men.
    • The Hetaira archetype is companion to man, related to the personal psychology of the man, as well as to her children and friend. Hetaira is the root of the word Hetaere – mistress. So reading between the line and her description, in essence Toni Wolff surely meant Eros (or Lover) which corresponds nicely with the male archetype of Thomas Moore and Douglas Gillette. They adopted and extended Jung’s approach in their exploration of the masculine psyche by using the collective archetypes of the King, the Warrior, the Magician, and the Lover, which I mapped to the female archetype quadruple  in my essay: Queen, Mother, Wise Woman and Lover: Rediscovering the Archetypes of the Mature Feminine here.
    • The Medial archetype  is immersed in the psychic atmosphere and the spirit of her period, but above all in the impersonal unconsciousness. In short, C.G. Jung would call that a seer or wise man, that sends or foretells us on a search for knowledge of all kinds: spiritual,metaphysical, gnostic, mystical, psychological, intellectual, scientific, political,  or outcome of future battles. I wrote about Sabina Spielrein in Female Archetype of Sabina Spielrein – queen or wise women?

    Anima and Animus unconscious elements of the psyche’s multiplicity

    From Jung’s observations during the analysis of his patients, he recognized the Anima and Animus to be unconscious elements of the psyche which needed to be developed, or made conscious,  to maintain a  balanced connection to the world at large and first step of individuation. The Anima in a man, Jung maintained, is a mostly personal image of Woman within his psyche which each man carries with him through life. This image, or inner psychic reality, is a composition of a man’s experiences of femininity from childhood on, which is combined also with ancestral and archaic collective impressions of femininity. Jung maintained that it was the Anima which was responsible for a man becoming attracted to women, but only certain women, those who are close in character to this inner experience of femininity in the man’s psyche. In women, the Animus plays a similar role of defining the masculine side of a woman’s personality. Logically Emma Jung’s major contribution ( influenced by Toni Wolff) is her expansion on the concept of the Animus in her first essay written 1931.  The Anima essay, written in 1955, presents fewer personal views, and relies more on myth, legend, and fairy tale. As her numerous references to mythologies show, Animus and Anima can affect a man and woman in regards to each other and in spiritual quest.

    On the way back through the rolling hills

    Moonlit Beauties. Luis Anima and Pantheism based on Ricardo Falero  . US Public Domain.
    Moonlit Beauties. Luis Anima and Pantheism based on Ricardo Falero . US Public Domain.

    On the way back, while driving during the incipient dusk in the rolling foot hills of the Bavarian Alps, we were both a bit tired after the dinner.  The conversation became simpler, but a little more personal. At one point he asked me about my marriage. “A real drag”  I said.  He responded : “How much of it you think comes from her menopause?  Somewhat cynical and blunt I quipped: Oh, a great part of it of course, I know that, but see I am a simple guy. If the sex is good – a woman can’t do hardly wrong, if the sex is bad – a woman can do little right. We had a very strong and good sexual relationship in our choppy enough marriage. Kind of glue. I know, that I have to transform my marriage, but all I could do was transferring to a decent truce and level of indifference.  Silence. We must have thought both, well consultants typically are immune to counseling, so we changed the subject.

    Tony Wolff’s structure of the Anima

    I understood pretty clearly, that all men pick their wife (the wealthy men, or those with wealthy wives – their mistress) unconsciously after their Anima. Even Jung (especially Jung) seems  a primary example to me. Toni Wolff, by the way was his mistress after Sabina Spielrein, who in turn is considered as catalyst for his Anima theory. Both women were gifted psychiatrists. Well, by chance I re-read Tony Wolff’s structure of the Anima today. Oops, now I understand my problem on a meta-level. Of course, the Anima doesn’t change, but time alters women. So that’s the meaning of the saying: Women want always to change their man and men  want their woman not to change. Unfortunately, both things never happen.  Eros may be for many men, the primary Anima “function”, as well as sexuality the primary path of communication, keeping the synchronization (or trust level) up.  So yesterday had been a Jungian psychoanalytic session on the steering  wheel. It has not solved my problem (yet), but sure was a great talk.

    Bibliography

    • Animus and Anima, Emma Jung
    • STRUKTURFORMEN DER WEIBLICHEN PSYCHE wolff Structural forms of the Feminine psyche (http://ufdc.ufl.edu/AA00001582/00001)
    • Jacobi, Jolande, Die Psychologie von C. G. Jung – Eine Einführung in das Gesamtwerk, mit einem Geleitwort von C. G. Jung [Gebundene Ausgabe]
    • Jung, C. G., Jaffé, A. (1962): Erinnerungen, Träume, Gedanken von C. G. Jung. Aufgezeichnet und herausgegeben von Aniela Jaffé. Olten: Walter
    • Jacobi, Jolande, Complex/Archetype/Symbol in the Psychology of C.G. Jung (Bollingen Series)
    • Mandala: Bilder aus dem Unbewussten (German Edition) [Hardcover] 2.Auflage Olten 1977
    • Jaffé, Aniela. Aufsätze zur Psychologic C. G. Jungs. (Essays on the psychology of C. G. Jung). Zürich, Daimon Verlag, 1982. Pp. 160. Paperback (The latter book I found in a heap of books in a second-hand shop)
    • Female Archetypes in Rome

    • The many lives of C. G. Jung – Memories, Dreams, Reflections by C.G. Jung, Aniela Jaffe, Clara Winston

    Shortly before his own death, C.G. Jung  finished his autobiographical book erinnerungen-traeume-gedanken. In addition, to  the extremely popular book “Man and his symbols”,  his most important theories of analytical psychology are summarized in a simple way in collaboration with his students. Supposedly a chapter about Toni Wolff has been removed on request of his family nor is Sabina Spielrein mentioned. I highly recommend this book to anyone interested in the life of Jung and the events in his life that influenced his work (edited by Aniela Jaffe) :

    Introduction by Aniela Jaffé
    Prolog
    Childhood
    Years of schooling
    Academic years
    Psychiatric activity
    Sigmund Freud
    The confrontation with the unconscious
    On the origin of the work
    The Tower
    Travel
    North Africa
    The Pueblo Indians
    Kenya and Uganda
    India
    Ravenna and Rome
    Visions
    About life after death
    Late thoughts
    Review
    Reprinting panels
    four essays on the work of Jung
    two on more personal aspects of his life

     

    Google

  • Female Archetype of Sabina Spielrein – queen or wise women?

    Female Archetype of Sabina Spielrein – queen or wise women?

    Sabina Spielrein (1885-1942) was a brilliant psychoanalytic pioneer in many ways —one of the first women to write a psychoanalytic dissertation, the leading pioneer in child psychology, and the true originator of the “death drive” (destruction as the cause of becoming) a full decade before Freud. Sometimes not the individual misses a moment of history, but fate or history itself rejects a significant person, choosing a darker alley rather than a great moment. This essay explores Spielrein’s contribution to psychoanalytic theory and her enigmatic live including  after she moved  back  to the USSR.

    When Jung and Spielrein had their intense romantic and intellectual entanglement between 1904 and 1909. According to letters it seems initially, Freud and Jung actually colluded to downplay her and paint her as a vengeful, unstable woman to protect Jung’s career. However after Jung split from Freud in 1913, the Freudians warmly welcomed Spielrein [into the Vienna Psychoanalytic Society] very likely partially because they realized they could use her intimate knowledge of Jung as an institutional weapon. Resembles her life the female archetype of the Queen (in exile), or Russian Jewish Wise Woman entangled with the two leading pioneers of the first hour of psychoanalysis – C. G. Jung and Sigmund Freud?

    By 1923, Spielrein was living and practicing in Geneva, entirely safe from the volatile political currents sweeping through Eastern Europe. However, Freud explicitly supported and encouraged her return to Soviet Russia to help establish and institutionalize psychoanalysis in Moscow. Besides ending deadly for herself and her three brothers, this served a dual, cynical purpose. It allowed Freud to plant the flag of psychoanalysis in the newly formed USSR and it permanently removed a (maybe too) brilliant, potentially vocal woman with inmate knowledge of the Freudian circle from the European intellectual center. She moved  back  to the USSR, shortly before Lenin’s death in January 1924. Her family was completely caught in the dual meat-grinders of the 20th century of the two totalitarian regimes of Stalin and Hitler.

    Scope and Structure

    Secret Symmetry
    Secret Symmetry

    Most know from Sabina Spielrein, that she was patient and presumably a lover of of C.G. Jung and later a psychoanalyst herself.  Spielrein, who could have been a decisive Jungian, switched sides to Freud and his narrow materialistic Viennese psychoanalyst school -certainly a founding stone but largely discarded clinical today. It seems to me that Freud (and to a lesser degree C.G. Jung) used and belittled her. Supposedly on advice of Freud Spielrein moved to Russia, conveniently forgotten by the psychoanalytical community and out of the way. After 1923 she has published only one scientific paper. Freud borrowed freely her ideas, and his daughter Ann assumed her role in child psychology.

    1942 Spielrein and her daughters vanished in a SS massacre on the Jewish community at Rostov on Don, Spielrein’s birthplace. Between August 2 and 11, 1942, the Einsatzgruppe D SS unit murdered up to 18,000 Jewish residents in a mass shooting at the Zmiyevskaya Balka (Snake Ravine). The exact names and stories of individual families from this tragedy are extremely difficult to locate.

    I like ponder the following questions about Sabina Spielrein:

    • Psychological Dimension
    • Theoretical work of Sabina Spielrein;
    • C.G. Jung and Sabina Spielrein
    • Sigmund Freud and Sabina Spielrein
    • Sabina Spielrein in Russia
    • Sabina Spielrein in psychoanalytic history

    I have touched the life of Sabina Spielrein in a former article briefly, but will try to approach her in this essay by her own accounts or those of C.G.Jung and Sigmund Freud:

    • Spielreins’s doctoral thesis and her famous publication  “Die Destruktion als Ursache des Werdens” Jahrbuch für psychoanalytische und psychopathologische Forschungen IV. Band 1912  (available as pdf).
    • Her recently discovered diary and letters to Jung and Freud published in  “A secret symmetry” by Aldo Carotenuto (original in Italian).
    • Sigmund Freud, Carl Gustav Jung Briefwechsel Freud / Jung Fischer Verlag 1974 (also available by Princeton University Press);
    • The second must-read scholarly analysis, “A Most Dangerous Method” by John Kerr, 1993.

    In order to get more historical and evidential context  I used:

    • History of the Bolshevik Revolution  by von Rauch (Wiesbaden 1955)
    • Historical Analyses around location and time listed in the reference section. Rostov on Don is located 500km (300mi) from the current Crimea  Crisis area.  The city, occupied by German troops twice, saw the first major retreat of the German forces in WWII on their way to Stalingrad.
    • Finally Marton’s somewhat dry documentary My Name Was Sabina Spielrein (2002) and the juicy edutainment  “A Dangerous Method (2011)” by David Cronenberg which may also be called a “A Marketable Distortion”. When dealing with historical characters, freedom of art does not allow a severely distorted portrayal.

    Please bear in mind this not a scholarly work buts an essay about a woman who deeply scarred by two major psychoanalytic schools, and who was destroyed by both of the twentieth century’s major totalitarian systems.

    The triangle –  Jung – Spielrein- Freud interaction

    jung sabina freud

    Throughout his life, Freud experienced competitive feelings in male-female-male triangles (John and Pauline; Wilhelm Fliess and Emma Eckstein ; C.G. Jung and Sabina Spielrein) with a male intimate companion.   It is perhaps ironic that when Sigmund Freud – who lived by the psychoanalytic theory that sexual desire was the prime driver for human beings – found out his young protégé, Carl Jung, was having an extra-marital affair with Sabina Spielrein. Sabina Spielrein, seems not the only female patient with whom C.G. Jung had an relationship, he was a decidedly heterosexual man of impressive stature, but it seems this one was serious by nature. In Spielrein’s letters she writes about wanting to have a “Aryan-semitic” child, and as she tests actually Freud’s theory with those of C.G. Jung it seems that really this is meant on a a metaphorical level – merging the two complete different psychoanalytic systems together.

    Freud was viewing Jung as protégé and innovative and original heir to psychoanalysis. Jung, however, soon questioned some of the basic tenets of Freudian theory. Freud’s reaction to the defection of Jung, and later that of Alfred Adler, was to close ranks and further guard his theories. C.G. Jung’s view fit nicely to contemporary thinking, that innovative conservatism, which is called for to protect freedom -and- the world environment as well as western heritage. C.G.Jung’s cultural roots were decisively neo-romantic drawn to symbolism and irrationality or at least mystic and he uniquely connected psychology and religion. In politics he questioned democracy and rejected socialism preferring elitism – like Nietzsche which is quoted extensively by Spielrein. Jung criticized also the rationalistic, “disenchanted” view of the world, Freud’s hostility against religions and contradicted him on many theses. Freud was to one-dimensional and a product of a special, narrow and bourgeois short overcome period, Freud not Jung became mainstream, Spielrein deserted Jung and of course Freud’s materialistic view appealed to the left.

    Psychological Dimension – Female Archetype of Sabina Spielrein

    Until 1980, Sabina Spielrein was represented in the work of Sigmund Freud in the psychoanalytic literature by four footnotes; also it is mentioned several times in the Freud-Jung correspondence (1974). Through her relationship with Jung, Sabina Spielrein had a direct effect on Jung’s own ideas, particularly the Animus. She was his first and prototype of Anima.  Her second paper talks about the death instinct a concept that Freud would later adapted as part of his own theory. These marginal existence, in psychoanalytical history only changed when you have a box of highly interesting material discovered late seventies during renovation work in the basement of the Palais Wilson in Geneva from the early days of psychoanalysis. Aldo Carotenuto, a Jungian analyst, was notified and immediately recognized the importance of the matter. It was Sabina Spielrein’s namely correspondence with Sigmund Freud and Carl Jung and her diary.

    Her diary and her letters to Freud and Jung constitute the greater part of  the book “Secret Symmetry” of Mr. Carotenuto, a Jungian analyst and a professor of psychology at the University of Rome. There are also a number of letters from Freud to Spielrein, but, most unfortunately, the Jung family will not release Jung’s letters to her, although Carotenuto has been allowed to quote from them.

    The subject –  her diary

    anima
    anima

    Over 25 years ago, diaries of Sabina Spielrein and letters she received from Jung and Freud were found in the basement of the Wilson Palace in Geneva (the Psychology Institute where she worked used to be there).

    The documents were published for the first time by Italian psychoanalyst Aldo Carotenuto. He understood that the discovered materials would once again confirm the liaison between Jung and his patient, his subsequent pupil, that Freud was also  involved there quite sinister. Carotenuto (either out of gentleman’s solidarity, or because of his respect to the founders of psychoanalysis) supplied the letters with polite comments.  The diary covers the years 1909 to 1912. They paint a picture of a bright, young completely healthy young woman concerned with her doctor thesis. It is also a good account to her time growing up, and shows also it seems the typical conflict of young Jewish female if they fall in love with a Christian man.

    Sabina Spielrein fell deeply in love with Jung during her treatment, a love that she knew must remain secret due to his marriage and the ethics of his profession. Jung was first attracted to Spielrein at Burghölzli. In the records at Burgholzli Hospital on his treatment of Spielrein, Jung wrote an entry in his own handwriting on January 29, 1905. He states that he had visited Spielrein the previous night, “reclining on the sofa.” He describes her manner as “oriental” and “voluptuous,” and her face as bearing “a sensuous, dreamy expression” (Covington and Wharton, 96.) Both Spielrein and Jung’s feelings for each other continued to deepen in subsequent years. They shared a passionate interest in psychoanalysis that further bonded them.

    The object – Letters between C.G. Jung and Sigmund Freud about “Die Kleine”

    Hidden Censorship
    Hidden Triple Agenda – Jung and Freud writing about Sabina

    Spielrein’s mental health “affliction” appeared at age seventeen, although she had been beset with problems throughout her young life. She was taken to the ( Burghölzli) Burgholzli Treatment and Care Institution (or Psychiatric Clinic) in Zurich on August 17, 1904. Spielrein became the first patient of Carl Jung, ten years her senior. She remained an out-patient in treatment  with Carl Jung for years after her hospital discharge June 1, 1905.  Jung wrote to Freud in October 1906 (one of their first letters (4J and 5F), seeking his opinion about a “severe case” he had involving a young female Russian student. During the course of her treatment, Sabina Spielrein became the friend and then most likely mistress of Jung. So almost one year later, in June 1907 he had to ask for advice again, telling Freud that Sabina Spielrein had made inappropriate demands to have a child with him and since he declined was badmouthing him. Indeed  the letters to Jung speak of an Semite-Aryan child ,she wanted to have with him, but that seems purely metaphorical. Freud responded professional, saying in essence that is the risk of their trade. Later the stormy love affair between Jung ans Spielrein that continued until the spring of 1909 was discussed between them. To what degree the relationship was sexual remains an inclusive subject. Jung eventually ended the affair, to save his marriage and his career. A rumor was maliciously circulated in Vienna and Zurich about an affair he allegedly had with a student. Initially, both Jung and Freud thought Spielrein was the origin of the scandal as an act of revenge against Jung for ending their relationship.

    Together, Jung and Freud plotted against her, later it seems Freud plotted against Jung. The next milestone was a letter from Freud to Jung in October 1911 telling him that Freud had admitted Spielrein in his Psychoanalytic Society (273F).  From that on about 10 letters refer to Spielrein’s publication in the context of an inferior pupil and an afterthought. Both men refer to her as “Die Kleine” with Jung always emphasizing how much work ans support she needs to correct her publications. Freud and Jung mostly share quite destructive criticism of her. In a letter and of march 1912 (F311) Freud  gives Jung a hint that he discussed with Spielrein same “intimate things”  with her (about her relationship with Jung).  After that the tone between Jung and Freud (and vice verso) becomes frosty and only few letter were exchanged.

    The Symbol – history and culture

    We are faced with the peculiar finding of psychoanalysis, the well-founded belief in the healing power of recollection, has been persistently objected in its own historicization.  Handing down of a wrong diagnosis – severely disturbed person with or with out sexual undertones – ensures that in the hagiography of psychoanalysis everything remains the same.

    The recent very Freud friendly movie “A Most Dangerous Method” put her gain in the category “sexual troubled” (not sure if pervert or liberated was suggested) focusing at a shallow relationship  triangle story  – sex sells. The juicy sex scenes seem to be dreamed up totally, as the most explicit you may find in the letters is “writing poems together. The history of psychoanalysis is littered with the discarded psyches of the women whose diagnoses were key to the fame of the great masters. One such woman was Sabina Spielrein.  At least Elisabeth Márton´s film “My name is Sabina Spielrein” relates, re-stages and remembers the tragic story of Spielrein’s life as gleaned from a box of her papers discovered in 1977 in the cellar of Geneva’s former Institute of Psychology.

    Sabina Spielrein, even after her death, fell victim to the severe struggle for affirmation of positions in  hierarchy or political viewpoints. Several years ago a work by Peter Kuter under the title Modern Psychology was published in Germany. The scientist depicted a genealogical tree of the psychoanalytical school and mentioned Sabina Spielrein. Russian scientists were astonished to see that when the book was translated into Russian in 1997 in St.Petersburg, the Spielrein was dropped off the genealogical tree.

    As always, history is the story of the past, told for present purpose, but the purpose stayed. the same and the patient psychoanalysis is not healed.

    Achievements of  Sabina Spielrein

    In 1911, Sabina wonderfully defended a thesis on the subject “On psychology of material on one schizophrenia case”. Sabina Spielrein’s most famous work, “Destruction as the Cause of Coming into Being” (Destruktion als Ursache des Werdens, 1912) . It envisions her neither as a premature Jungian nor as a dissident Freudian, but as what she truly was: an independent theorist whose dialectic of creation and destruction in transformation occupies the intellectual space between Freud’s metapsychology and Jung’s later psychology of individuation and the collective unconscious. Spielrein, a Russian psychoanalyst, argues that creation and destruction are inseparable. Her core insight is that genuine transformation requires the dissolution of an existing form—a law that applies equally across the biological, philosophical, psychological, and symbolical realms. Sabina Spielrein’s November 29 entry presentation to the Vienna Psychoanalytic Society, bearing the working title “Über Transformation,” was a preview of her finalized 1912 paper, “Die Destruktion als Ursache des Werdens”. Her work seems inherently more Jungian than Freudian, at the crucial points, she politely disagreed with Freud—she is Sabina Spielrein. Among her Viennese colleagues, Spielrein’s presentation was therefore met with massive resistance. Freud himself was not yet ready to her ideas; it was not until his 1920 essay, “Beyond the Pleasure Principle,” that he would finally acknowledge Spielrein’s work—misunderstanding and pressing it squarely in his rigid orthodoxy and relegating Spielstein’s work to a mere footnote. He entertained the idea of a strong connection between a new instinct Thanatos and Eros, the instinct of death and the instinct of creation.

    Spielrein has been considered by some as the model for Jung’s concept of the anima. She deepened both Jung and Freud’s understanding of transference and counter-transference. The relationship between Jung and Spielrein  demonstrated that a therapist’s emotions and humanity could not be kept out of the psychoanalytic relationship between analyst and patient. Freud claimed as cold materialist, using science as shield and serious front-end, psychoanalysts would be able to function from an objective and neutral position in their work. C.G. Jung spiraled in the most productive crises after his split, (with Spielrein and Freud),but eventually stabilized  became an accomplished empirical psychoanalyst  and continued to have outside affairs with pupils and colleagues (next  in line was Toni Wolff).

    It is hard to explain the oblivion into which Spielrein fell until recently. Neither Ernest Jones in his standard work on Freud (1953), nor Peter Gay’s magnum opus, Freud (1987), nor even Nancy Chodorow, who wrote on the contribution of women to psychoanalysis (1987), mention her in their writings. Her primary role in child psychology has been wrongly attributed to Anna Freud or, alternatively, to Melanie Klein.

    Despite of that, Spielrein pioneering work in their specialty area child analysis have remained unnoticed. In psychoanalytic reception still Freud’s daughter Anna or Melanie Klein is regarded the founder of child psychoanalysis At this time twenty-five publications of Spielrein were published, ten of them dealing with  child-analytical issues. We must ask ourselves: What forces are at work here and foreclose psychoanalysis from remembering and historicization of their origin mythology?

    The making of a psychoanalyst

    Sabina Spielrein enrolled in the spring of 1905 at the medical faculty of the University of Zurich and rents a room in district, which is called on Zurich « Russian colony ” Although Sabina Spielrein does not need to worry financially, their years of study in Zurich are difficult and overshadowed by her relationship with Jung. It has become more complex , oscillating between therapeutic relationship , idealized teacher – student relationship , friendship and love affairs. In the winter semester 1910/11 Sabina Spielrein concludes the study of medicine. In her dissertation , she examines “the psychological content of a case of schizophrenia ( dementia praecox )”, which was the first psychoanalytic dissertation of a woman. It proves Spielrein linguistic sensibility and talent in capturing and deciphering of unconscious mental processes. The text was published 1911 as first dissertation ever in the ” Yearbook for Psychoanalytical and Psycho-pathological Research ”  .

    The summer semester spends Spielrein in Munich, where she writes here comprehensive meta-psychological speculation. The theme develops a theory that the sex drive consists of two antagonistic components a ” creative” and a ” destructive instinct “. The text ” Destruction as cause of becoming ” will be 1912 also published in the prestigious  Yearbook  side by side with an article of C.G. Jung. Her most famous publication entitled Destruction as the Cause of Coming into Being which mentioned before was published in 1912. Although praise and multiple references to her by C.G. Jung, the article fell with her into obscurity after she moved back to Russia.

    In April 1912 Sabina Spielrein returned to Rostov and married the Russian-Jewish doctor Pawel Naumovich Sheftel, but the couple moved to Berlin , where Sabina gives birth in December 1913 to her first daughter. Shortly after the beginning of  first World War II , we find her again in Zurich and Sabina Spielrein spends her last three years in Switzerland  in Geneva. She published several articles in professional journals and lectures on psychoanalysis and education at the Institute Rousseau and works clinically and makes training analyzes of , among others, Jean Piaget. During World War I, Spielrein continued to live in Switzerland while her husband remained in Russia fighting with his regiment based in Kiev. From 1914 to 1923 Dr. Sheftel had lived with Olga Snitkova with whom he fathered daughter Nina in Russia while married with Sabina who lived and worked in Switzerland

    C.G. Jung and Sabina Spielrein

    In the summer of 1904 her parents sent Sabina to the Burghoelzli mental hospital in Switzerland; the diagnose was mental hysteria (debilitating hysterical/sexual complex). When she was first admitted, Jung described Spielrein as being unable to look anyone in the face, keeping her head bowed and sticking out her tongue ”with every sign of loathing” if anyone touched her. Attacks of depression alternated with weeping, laughing and screaming. The eighteen year old girl Sabina Spielrein and a thirty year old unknown doctor C. G. Jung started as of a patient-doctor relationship with a powerful transference and counter-transference between Spielrein and Jung. Jung was troubled by the strong emotions his former patient stirred in him and sought out advice on the matter from Freud, thus beginning their correspondence and relationship. Being convinced of the ideas of Sigmund Freud, he applied methods of the psychoanalyst from Vienna on Sabina for the first time. Jung described success of medical treatment of the young Russian girl with usage of these methods in letters to his friend and teacher.

    Jung didn’t conceal the fact that Sabina fell in love with him (it is frequent in medical practice when female patients attribute features of a hero, father or God on their doctors). He wrote, the girl “sincerely” told she wanted to give birth to his son whom she wanted to name Siegfried. The liaison between Sabina Spielrein and Carl Gustav Jung lasted for five years. It may be that these relations turned out to be some kind of a catalyst for C.G. Jung scientific development and luring Sabina Spielrein away from Jung. Freud wrote to Sabina: “We will be happy to meet you even further if you wish to stay with us, but you must learn to discern the difference between friends and enemies (I mean Jung).”

    The medical treatment went successfully. In a year Sabina felt perfectly well, and the head physician of the clinic and boss of C.G. Jung, famous psychiatrist Eugen Bleuler allowed Jung to let his patient to enroll at the Zurich University medical school for studies.

    Letters between Spielrein and C.G. Jung

    For years Spielrein moved endlessly, seemingly incapable of settling anywhere or with anyone. Meanwhile, says Kerr, ‘Jung was busy making her immortal.’ In the years following the First World War, Jung developed a means of categorizing the conscious. He invested the Anima with all sorts of qualities, some exhilarating and some dangerous which, Jung wrote, he’d recognized in ‘a woman… a patient, a talented psychopath who had become a living figure in my mind’. Jung’s Anima model was Sabina Spielrein.

    Spielrein corresponded with Jung until at least 1919 and with Freud until 1923. The published letters cover the years 1911 to 1918 with forty six letters from Jung (only quoted unfortunately not released) and twelve of Spielrein. The topics are strictly of psychoanalytical content.

    Jung was married with two children, and it is clear that his relationship with Spielrein was inappropriately intimate (whether it was sexual or not is not proven).  Jung and Spielrein’s letters discussed theory at length. Just as Jung and Freud became increasingly distrustful of each other and possessive of their ideas, so too did Jung and Spielrein.

    When he read her university dissertation on schizophrenia Jung told her, ‘I am surprised by the abundance of excellent thoughts, which anticipate various ideas of my own. But it is good that others see things the same way as I do.’

    He commented on to her next paper, ‘Destruction as a Cause of Coming into Being’ (written immediately after she graduated with top honors),  ‘As I read your paper I find uncanny parallels with my own new work.’  Spielrein clearly exploded, for his next letter exclaims, ‘You are upsetting yourself unnecessarily again!’ His reassurance that, ‘your study is extraordinarily intelligent and contains splendid ideas whose priority I am happy to acknowledge as yours,’ is undercut by his assertion that, ‘I express myself so differently from you in my work that no one could imagine you had borrowed from me.’

    Sigmund Freud and Sabina Spielrein

    Spielrein also sought help from Freud, initially requesting a consultation with him in 1909, but Freud declined due to his discussions with Jung about his relationship with Spielrein. Spielrein eventually met Freud in Vienna in October 1911. He was greatly impressed with her.

    In autumn 1911 leaves Zurich and moves to Vienna to work with Sigmund Freud. Spielrein became an elected member of the Vienna Psychoanalytic Society. She is now twenty-five. The minutes of the club meetings show that they vividly involved in the discussions and lectures. Freud earns to appreciate and even sends her patients. There has always been a question about the extent of the relationship between Freud and Spielrein on many levels, and also about just how much of her work Freud may have adopted as his own, giving her little or no credit. Dr. Spielrein’s life ended in obscurity when she was only 55, Freud continued to increase in stature and reputation.

    At that time, Freud listened to the report of the young psychoanalyst indulgently and said the speech was “logically well-composed”. Only in several years, he himself expressed the dual theory of attractions; at that he didn’t refer to Spielrein’s report delivered in 1911, that anticipated Freud’s later ideas of attraction to death. In 1930, when Freud once again mentioned his former resistance to the theory of attractions, not a single word was said that criticism of that kind was given in response to Sabina Spielrein’s article.

    Letters between Spielrein and Sigmund Freud

    The published letters cover the years 1909 to 1920 with twenty letters from Freud (fortunately included) and two of Spielrein. The first May 30th 1909 reads like a job application. The next is already an request to mediate between her and C.G. Jung. The last fragments talks about her about “declaring her self to “our (Psychoanalytical) Society” a “treachery which Dr. J. cannot forgive”. She first wrote to Sigmund Freud in 1909, met him in 1911 in Vienna, and continued meeting and corresponding with him at least until 1923, to some eventually developing into more of Freudian than a Jungian in her work.

    A women which wants to make it, has an affair with her analyst which happens to be also important for her psychoanalytic career. She consults 1909 another analyst – which happens to be the psychoanalytic father disappointed from his heir – to help sort out her ensuing problems. A tricky situation, for the analysts even and especially if the analysts were Jung and Freud in a love hate relationship. Spielrein continued to correspond also with Jung and Freud during this time, despite the destructive split that occurred between the two men in 1912.

    In a 1909 letter to Freud she writes: ”Four and a half years ago Dr. Jung was my doctor, then be became my friend and finally my ‘poet,’ i.e., my beloved. Eventually he came to me and things went as they usually do with ‘poetry.’ He preached polygamy; his wife was supposed to have no objection, etc., etc.” By 1909 Jung was trying to separate from her emotionally but continued to see her and gave her help with her dissertation. In 1910 Spielrein records that at one time Jung gave her his diary to read and said that no one else could understand him so well as she did. Then he abruptly alters his tone, addresses her formally in letters and signs himself ”Dr. Jung.” Spielrein confides in her mother, who has received an anonymous letter which says that Jung is ruining her daughter. Her mother writes to Jung, to whom she is obviously grateful for the great improvement in her daughter’s condition, begging him ”not to exceed the bounds of friendship.” Jung writes back an appalling letter.

    Spielrein then writes to Freud asking to see him. As usual, Freud behaves outwardly correct. He writes to Jung requesting information. Jung reveals that Spielrein is a patient about whom Freud knows something already, since not only was she the subject of a lecture given by Jung in Amsterdam but she was also the person referred to in an earlier letter to Freud in which Jung complained that a woman patient had ”kicked up a vile scandal solely because I denied myself the pleasure of giving her a child.” Jung goes on, ”I have always acted the gentleman towards her, but before the bar of my rather too sensitive conscience I don’t feel clean. …” In a subsequent letter, Jung reveals that he has seen Spielrein again, that she was not the author of the rumors he had attributed to her and that he himself was to blame, not only for encouraging her but also for trying to defend himself ”in a manner that cannot be justified morally.’

    The Freudian Case against Spielrein

    The reappearance of Spielrein ‘s diaries, letters and  scientific publications in the eighties were not taken on by the Freudian psychoanalysis as kick-off to revitalize memory. Rather, Spielrein was subsequently honored with a distorted, one-sided form diagnosis  of severe mental disorder , a psychotic who broke with reality. Aldo Carotenuto called it ” veritable schizophrenic episode ,” Bruno Bettelheim a ” schizophrenic disorder ” or a ” severe hysteria with schizoid features ” ; Max Day spoke of ” borderline “. Happily Freudian took C.G. Jung (!) as witness , who presented the “Case Spielrein” at the International Congress of Psychiatry and Neurology in 1907 in Amsterdam.

    A closer look shows that Sabina was not the lunatic ill patient not, as today’s analyst – about Carotenuto, Bruno Bettelheim or Max Day – want to make us believe. Sabina has been able to exploit the situation in Burghoelzli and developed a perspective that suited their preferences and their talent. So Jung and Spielrein got over a rapidly developing crisis. Soon after she sits  – herself still patient – on the doctors table, participating in the clinic’s health studies and deals with diagnosis. It shows a remarkable success of Jung’s theory and practice – and that some very gifted psychoanalyst have crises on her own. C.G. Jung was smart enough to forbid the document of his crisis during lifetime, probably aware of the dangers of an “vicious psychoanalytical community” as a friend of mine, a Jungian psychoanalyst, liked to refer to both psychoanalytic schools.

    Conflicts of and between Sigmund Freud and C.G. Jung

    Sigmund Freud and C. G. Jung  began  to correspond with each other in April 1906. During the next seven years they corresponded regularly, usually at intervals of a few days. This extensive correspondence of approximately 360 letters  has been published 1974  for the first time. The  Freud–Jung relationship dominated the history of the psychoanalytic movement, until relations were finally severed early in 1912. If you read their published correspondence today, it is impossible to distinguish issues of passionate friendship, academic rivalry and theoretical conflict in their relationship. Freud was explicitly looking for a son and heir for the psychoanalytic movement. Jung seemed both to be seeking a father figure for his psychic security but soon rebelled against him.

    The major Player- Jung, Salome, Elijah
    The major players in the Red Book- Jung, Salome, Elijah

    After years of exchange differences between Jung and Freud became increasingly evident 1912. Besides the professional dissent the conflict comes to a head until the opposites finally be unbridgeable. It is exciting to witness based on the selected documents the inevitable entanglement to its tragic failure. As with the correspondence between Spielrein, Freud and Jung the correspondence between Jung and Freud has become essential to understanding the evolution of psychoanalysis – and the virtually insurmountable challenges facing woman who sought to contribute in any role other than that of patient, pupil, wife, daughter, lover or groupie with or without scientific credentials. But also the vicious underpinnings of the “publish an perish” science. Both man belittled Sabina Spielrein and she after she switched sides, Spielrein became dangerous to Jung and was used by Freud. 

    For Jung, Spielrein’s company as patient, pupil and lover in those days may have triggered partially his career breakthrough but surely may have led breaking away from Freud. In “Memories, Dreams, Reflections”, Jung seemed to indicate that all his most important insights stemmed from his unconscious fantasies in the years 1913–18 during his creative illness after the break with Freud and Sabina Spielrein. The overlay with letters from Spielrein show remarkable ambitious women and her undeniable talents consciously or unconsciously deepened the conflict between the two alpha men.

    By taking her in the Freudians effectively “owned” the scandal and utilized the narrative of Jung’s boundary violation to paint him as unprincipled, unprofessional, and psychologically unhinged, using Spielrein’s past trauma as ammunition in their corporate war against Swiss Analytical Psychology. Once the Freudians had used Spielrein to damage Jung’s reputation, they took advantage of her intellectually and then erased her from the history books. In 1920, Freud published Beyond the Pleasure Principle, introducing the “Death Instinct” (Thanatos). He relegated Spielrein—the woman who had introduced this exact concept to him in 1911—to a brief, dismissive footnote, claiming her ideas were too closely tied to her own “neurotic complexes”.

    Its pure speculation, but I could envision both men were happy when she left Switzerland and was no trouble anymore. If so, for very different reasons.

    Certainly, at this point, his former patient Toni Wolff became a necessary substitute to C.G. Jung.  Toni Wolff became the established mistress and important collaborator. During this crises  Jung created the Red Book, published posthumous much later, which was to together with the Seven Sermons to the Dead, the seed of his work. Jung was plagued by visions of blood, an underground river with a blond male corpse, a scarab, a red new sun in the prelude to the First World War. A brown-skinned man  told him to kill the hero, Siegfried. A fantasy figures of Elijah accompanied by a young girl, Salome taught him about the importance of the unconscious. A number of studies have noticed what is pretty evident if you study the Red book, that, in Elijah and Salome, he had versions of the two important people he had just lost, Freud and Sabina Spielrein.

    For Spielrein the separation has been a disaster which has still has consequences today.
    Sigmund Freud safely managed his institutional legacy from Vienna and London. Anna Freud inherited his empire. Meanwhile, the woman who provided the raw intellectual architecture for their most famous late-stage theories was sent away which turned into harms way, her papers left rotting in a Geneva basement for over half a century.

    Spielrein was the first to systematically analyze young children’s speech, play, and developmental cycles. After Spielrein was safely isolated in Russia, Anna Freud stepped into the Western vacuum, published heavily on child psychology using virtually identical clinical frameworks, and was crowned the “mother of child psychoanalysis”—effectively absorbing Spielrein’s life’s work without giving her due historical credit.

    Sabina Spielrein in Russia after 1923

    Sabina would have made a wonderful career if she had made it there stayed in Europe.  But on recommendation of Sigmund Freud, Sabina Spielrein got back to Russia. For 1.5 years she lived in Moscow, then she moved to Rostov, where she lectured at the University and worked as a doctor.

    Only few in the Russia or her hometown Rostov on Don, where Sabina was born, studied and later perished, know details of her private life and scientific activity. The woman is still a mystery, even now and despite the fact she always involved with public figures  as friends, doctors or teachers.

    Freudian bloom

    Sabina Spielrein
    Sabina Spielrein

    In 1923, yielding to calls from parents, brothers and husband, as well as to Freud’s urging her “to accomplish important work at the side of Wulff and Ermakov” in Moscow, she returned to Russia.

    In spite of the mantle of Freud and successes in Moscow, e.g., lecturing and teaching at the State Psychoanalytic Institute, as head of the section on child psychology at Moscow University and had an appointment at the State Psychoanalytic Institute and co-worker at the State Children’s Home and Laboratory “International Solidarity,” Spielein abruptly returned to Rostovand reconciled with her husband Sheftel  in 1924 and in June 1926 their second daughter Eva was born. The Bolsheviks printed Freud’s writings. Under patronage of Trotsky, the Russian psychoanalysis (strictly speaking Freudian) experienced at the beginning of the twenties a short bloom. The Bolshevik revolution, already ruthless by Lenin’s design, succumbed after Lenin’s death to evil and inhuman Stalin. Under his rule, the USSR degenerated into a brutal tyranny of its own, aptly symbolized in George Orwell’s book “Animal Farm”.  After the intellectual flamboyant Leon Trotsky (chosen by Lenin as his successor) had to emigrate to Mexico, all intellectuals in the Soviet Union were in great danger. Trotsky was killed 1938 with an ice pick by a Stalinist agent, in Mexico-City. Intellectuals, who stayed, had either to adapt totally and opportunistically or perish in a niche. After 1925, when Stalin began repressing psychoanalysis, would have been risky. Spielrein worked as school medical psychologist. Spielrein must have chosen the latter, she moved from Moscow for Rostov on Don, from then on working mostly practical-therapeutic.

    Recently discovered personal information sheet of the Soviet People’s Commissariat of National Education , ” Narkompros ” , confirm that Spielrein had from September 1923 three appointments: as a research assistant at the State Psychoanalytic Institute in Moscow, as pedagogical doctor in the town of the Third International (a type of children’s village ) as well as Head of the Section of child psychology at the First Moscow University. In Moscow Spielrein founded together with Ivan Ermakov Dimitrievitch and Moshe Wulff, the first Institute for Psychoanalysis in the Soviet Union. It was also the first state psychoanalytic training institute in the world.  1921-1924 of the Psychoanalytic Institute experiments were performed with liberal collective education in early childhood in the orphanage Laboratory, which served the ’68 movement as a model for their sexually charged socialist children shops.

    Communist Terror

    Sabina Spielrein’s clinical work was directly caught in the crossfires of the lethal political war between Joseph Stalin and Leon Trotsky. In the early 1920s, Leon Trotsky was the premier champion of psychoanalysis in the USSR. Trotsky believed that Sigmund Freud’s theories could be synthesized with Marxism to forge the “New Soviet Man.” He personally funded and protected the State Psychoanalytic Institute and the Moscow “White Kindergarten” (Detski Dom). Then psychoanalysis in the Soviet Union became prohibited.

    Because Trotsky had explicitly sponsored these institutions, psychoanalysis became deeply branded as a “Trotskyite deviation.” When Stalin consolidated power and exiled Trotsky, he systematically liquidated everything his rival had touched. Spielrein brothers had become successful scientists and became in the cross hair just by indirect association.

    Following the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, the opening of the [KGB/NKVD archives] confirmed the chilling, bureaucratic precision with which Stalin’s apparatus liquidated Sabina Spielrein’s brilliant family. Her three brothers were leading Soviet intellectuals, and their files in the Declassified NKVD Execution Archives reveal a textbook operation of the Great Terror of the late thirties:

    1. Isaak Spielrein (Arrested 1935, Executed 1937)

    Isaak was a world-renowned psychological genius who founded the Soviet field of Psychotechnics (the psychology of industrial labor).

    • The Charge: Because his scientific work in the 1920s had been praised, utilized, and personally funded by Leon Trotsky, the NKVD targeted him the moment Trotsky was exiled. Declassified files show he was arrested in January 1935 under the fabricated charge of being a leader in a “Trotskyite-Zinovievite Counter-Revolutionary Terrorist Organization.”
    • The Execution: After two years of brutal psychological isolation, he was sentenced to death by the Military Collegium of the Supreme Court of the USSR. NKVD records show he was shot on December 26, 1937, and buried in a mass grave at the infamous Kommunarka firing range outside Moscow.

    2. Jan Spielrein (Arrested 1937, Executed 1938)

    Jan was a brilliant mathematician, physicist, and a member of the USSR Academy of Sciences. He was completely apolitical, dedicated entirely to engineering and electrification.

    • The Charge: Under Stalin’s paranoiac directives, simply having a brother who was labeled a “Trotskyite spy” made Jan an immediate target of the NKVD’s group-guilt quotas. He was arrested in 1937 on charges of espionage and sabotage of Soviet technical infrastructure.
    • The Execution: Declassified court logs reveal his trial lasted less than fifteen minutes. He was found guilty without defense counsel and shot on January 21, 1938.

    3. Emil Spielrein (Arrested 1937, Executed 1938)

    Emil was a respected biologist and the Dean of the Faculty of Natural Sciences at Rostov State University.

    • The Charge: Like his brothers, his proximity to Western scientific circles and his family name sealed his fate. He was arrested during the sweeping purges of the regional academic elite in 1937.
    • The Execution: He was convicted of counter-revolutionary propaganda and shot on June 20, 1938.

    The declassified files show that by mid-1938, Sabina Spielrein was left entirely alone, her family utterly decimated by the Soviet state. The state officially stripped her of her medical licenses and academic titles because she was the sister of three “enemies of the people.”

    This explains why she was forced into deep poverty, working as a marginalized music teacher in Rostov-on-Don. She survived Stalin’s NKVD only to be caught in the path of Hitler’s SS Einsatzgruppe four years later—a tragic, perfect illustration of Jung’s warning that when human beings lose their connection to individual morality, the totalitarian state functions as a meat-grinder

     It was a hard life, Sabina aged rapidly, a bent woman, wearing old-fashioned clothes and shoes. The husband died of a heart attack in 1937. Thereafter Spielrein made a friendship pact with Olga Snitkova to take care of each other’s children in case one predeceased the other.
    .

    The many deaths of Sabina Spielrein –  unreliable sources

    Aldo Carotenuto assumed 1982 in his book “Secret Symmetry” Spielrein’s death year around 1937 which would connect hers to the fate of her brothers. Spielrein’s death may remains a mystery to me at least in the web – which comes up with three dates for her death but no real proof.

    • According to many web articles “Swedish journalist M. Ljunggren”, had discovered her fate. I have found no primary sources for this on the web yet. I did find a David Ljunggren, a journalist who speaks English, French, Russian and was stationed from 1989 to 1995 in Moscow where he covered the collapse of the Soviet Union.
    • In the book, “Sabina Spielrein: Forgotten Pioneer of Psychoanalysis” it is written that Dr. Ljunggren supposedly brought evidence that she was killed 1941 – which would be during the first occupation which lasted only eight days.
    • There is indeed a Magnus (M) Ljunggren, who professor for Russian literature. In the book of Andre Karger / Christoph Weismüller (Editors) “Ich hieß Sabina Spielrein – Von einer, die auszog, Heilung zu suchen” he contibuted a chapter about Sabina und Isaak Spielrein.

    However, the only base (and a credible one too) of all those repeated net claims seems to come from Henry Zvi Lothane or Henry Lothane,  a clinical professor of Psychiatry, at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York. He wrote in a short paper that the wive and  Isaak’s wife and daughter Menikha survived in Central Asia. According to him  Menikha Isaakovna a physiologist and biochemist, was discovered in 1982 in Moscow by the Swede Magnus Ljunggren. Menikha Isaakovn had a perfect command of German. Henry Zvi Lothan quotes now a letter of Menikha Isaakovna in 1994:

    “In November 1937 I decided to travel to Rostov, to my grandfather. Sabina asked me whether I believed what was being written in our newspapers about the cruelties perpetrated by Germans. She added, she had lived for many years in Germany and could not believe what is being printed in our newspapers, since she knows the high level of the German culture, of the people who gave the world Goethe, Heine, Schiller and many well known and outstanding people. I told her that I believe what was written about the Germans, I told us many stories and gave us underground literature from Germany, publications with descriptions of Nazi crimes. Obviously, I was unable to convince her. Cut off from contacts with the West, Spielrein did not know what was going on in Germany nor was she aware of Jung’s boundless admiration for the Nazis, inspired by Hitler’s Mein Kampf, aired on Radio Berlin in 1933.

    The first occupation of Rostov during WW II lasted for 8 days in November of 1941 whereupon the Germans were repulsed by the Red Army. On July 27 1942 the Germans reoccupied the city. Last time Spielrein was seen in August marching with her daughters in a long column of some 27,000 Jews towards the immense Zmeyovskaia ravine, on the outskirts of Rostov: all were gunned down and thrown into the mass grave, where a museum now stands. Some commentators saw in Spielrein’s staying there as acting out her death instinct, a case of wild analysis, trivializing her martyrdom. In the hospital she wrote her last will: on her grave an oak be planted in her memory with a sign “I was once a human being and my name was Sabina Spielrein” while another inscription read: “And let young life play at the entrance of the tomb and let indifferent nature shine with outer splendor”.

    In any case, of all the quotes about Spielrein’s death in her many historizations, Henry Zvi Lothan’s quote seem genuine and plausible, but it has to be noted, it reads like second or even third hearsay of an unknown source. There is a gap – Menikha seems not have stayed in Rostov between 1937 and 1942.

    Spielrein’s Notes vs. Rigid Marxist Pedagogy

    The Moscow “White Kindergarten” (founded by Vera Schmidt, with Spielrein as its chief clinician) was closed by the state because its psychological findings flatly contradicted the rigid, mechanical dogma of Marxist pedagogy.


    Sabina Spielrein’s Clinical Approach vs. Marxist Pedagogy
    Human Nature
    Driven by complex, autonomous, internal forces (the unconscious, ancestral archetypes, and deep biological drives).
    A tabula rasa (blank slate); human beings have no innate psychology and are shaped entirely by material conditions and state conditioning.
    Child Development
    Children process the world dynamically through individual play, speech, fantasies, and working through internal conflicts.
    Children must be collectively conditioned into a productive, standardized labor resource for the state.
    Authority & Growth
    Strict, authoritarian suppression forces natural drives to mutate into destructive complexes or severe neuroses.
    Total, unyielding collective discipline is mandatory; individual deviation is a bourgeois defect.
    The “New Soviet Man”
    Can only be achieved through deep self-awareness, emotional liberation, and psychological healing.
    Is manufactured by the state through rigorous political indoctrination and physical labor.

    The Clash of Clinical Reality

    Spielrein’s actual clinical notes from this period show that she observed children acting out, displaying sexual curiosity, and expressing deeply ingrained aggressive impulses (her concept of the destruction drive).

    To the Bolshevik state post Trotsky , these clinical notes were offensive heresy. Marxist pedagogy demanded that children be treated as purely rational, malleable cogs. If a child was aggressive or unstable, the state did not want a therapist investigating their subconscious; they blamed it on “corrupt bourgeois parenting.”

    By the late 1920s, Stalinist officials launched a vicious campaign against pedology (child psychology). They condemned the White Kindergarten as a “perverted, bourgeois, psychoanalytic distortion” that over-emphasized sexuality and individuality over class solidarity. The school was shut down, psychoanalysis was completely banned, and Spielrein’s life’s work was locked away in state archives.


    The intersections of her life show how terrifyingly accurate Jung’s warnings were: when the state becomes a dogmatic religion, it hunts down the scientists of the soul.

    How Lev Vygotsky Secretly Saved Spielrein’s Insights

    During Spielrein’s time in Moscow, both Alexander Luria and Lev Vygotsky came to work at the Psychoanalytic Institute and “Dyetski Dom” and studied with her. Spielrein’s method combining subjective psychological ideas from psychoanalysis with objective observational research of children is likely to have been an important influence on them. When Joseph Stalin officially banned psychoanalysis, pedology, and child psychology in the late 1920s, scholars who referenced Sigmund Freud or Carl Jung faced exile or execution. Lev Vygotsky (the father of Soviet developmental psychology) and his colleague Alexander Luria realized that Sabina Spielrein’s brilliant clinical discoveries would be destroyed if they remained attached to her name or to psychoanalysis.

    To preserve her life’s work, Vygotsky acted as an intellectual smuggler, stripping her theories of their “bourgeois psychoanalytic” vocabulary and translating them into standard Marxist, materialist language:

    • The Translation of “The Unconscious” into “Inner Speech”: Spielrein was the absolute pioneer of studying child language, tracking how a child’s private babble or fantasies reflect internal, unconscious needs. Vygotsky took this exact data and re-labeled it “Inner Speech” in his famous Cultural-Historical Theory. He argued that a child talking to themselves isn’t acting out deep Freudian drives, but is rather using a tool to internalize social language. This semantic shift allowed her clinical data to survive Soviet censorship.
    • The “Missing Link” Between Piaget and Vygotsky: Spielrein had psychoanalyzed a young Jean Piaget in Geneva before working with Vygotsky in Moscow. She discovered that children’s thoughts develop through a dialectical tension between individual biology and social interaction. Vygotsky leveraged Spielrein’s intimate knowledge of Piaget to construct his own famous critiques of Piaget’s work, essentially using Spielrein’s mind as the silent bridge for his own theories.
    • Submerging the Individual into the Social: Spielrein pioneered the idea that language is inherently relational—a tool to connect the self to another. Vygotsky absorbed this, stating that all higher mental functions originate as social interactions. By scrubbing the psychoanalytic focus on individual neurosis and framing it as a socio-cultural process, Vygotsky successfully hid her foundational concepts inside the bedrock of Soviet education.

    Because Vygotsky safely hid these ideas inside state-approved textbooks, her core concepts outlived Stalinism and eventually shaped global educational structures—even though Vygotsky himself never dared to cite her name in his late works out of sheer terror for his own life.

    Fascist Terror

    It is very possible even beyond doubt, that Sabina Spielrein met a tragic end in her hometown 1942. As a strategic bridgehead, Rostov suffered in World War II  twice the occupation by the German Wehrmacht. It is a fact, that when Hitler’s troops conquered the strategic city on 27 July 1942 the second time, tens of thousands of civilians were killed. According to repeated copy cat web entries Sabina Spielrein was last seen by neighbors in the summer of 1942 , supported by her two daughters, Renata and Eva, in a group of Jews. It is another fact, that during the occupation civilians and captured Red Army commissars were driven through the streets to the outskirts ; there, in the deep gorge that is called Zmiyevskaya Balka (the Snake Gully) they were killed by men of command 10a from the “Einsatzgruppe D”. Mainly consisting of Security Police and the SD (Sicherheitsdienst) as well as Gestapo, this special non-military forces were mobile and partly stationary ideologically trained mass murders, reporting directly to  SS leader Heinrich Himmler.  In accordance with different sources, there are 18-27 thousand people in that common grave, and each of them was with his individual story. Sabina Spielrein with her daughters Renata, 29, a talented cellist, and Eva, 14, who could have become a wonderful violinist shared this fate. Her husband had died a few years earlier..

    It has been also said  that in the years after the first occupation of Rostov, that even in 1941 Sabina Spielrein refused to leave the native city or to hide.  She explained the decision not to leave Rostov to the second wife of her husband. Before the war, the abandoned women understood perfectly well that each of them may be sent to the Soviet GULAG camps, that is why they agreed that the one who remains alive will bring up all children.Scientist Movshovich studying history of the Rostov region wrote: “By the time of the second occupation of Rostov, Spielrein very likely had already no illusions anymore”. However, all the same she refused to save her daughters: a friend of Sabina’s offered to give forged documents to the girls as they could have passed for Armenians. It is a mystery why Sabina Spielrein several times rejected methods of salvation.

    How does Russia sees Sabina Spielrein’s work today?

    The answer is a fascinating, deeply complicated paradox. It split cleanly between a localized, academic cultural pride and a broader state ideological friction.

    The Rostov Revival

    On a regional and civic level, there has been a remarkable, grassroots effort to reclaim Spielrein as a great Russian intellectual hero. This is a dramatic reversal from the Soviet era, when she and her work were completely erased.

    • The Spielrein Mansion Museum: In 2015, an official Sabina Spielrein Memorial Museum was opened inside her childhood home on Pushkinskaya Street in Rostov-on-Don. It features a permanent exhibition of her photographs, personal belongings, and a plaque honoring her as a “famous student of C.G. Jung and S. Freud”.
    • Immersive Tourism: Local historians and theater groups have developed immersive tours (like “The Forgotten Drama of the Spielrein House”) celebrating her life. In the Russian south, she is viewed as a brilliant, homegrown pioneer of global science.
    • Holocaust Memory: Her tragic murder, along with her daughters, at Zmievskaya Balka (the “Snake Gully”) in 1942 is recognized in Russia as part of the tragedy of the Great Patriotic War, anchoring her legacy to the national memory of overcoming Nazi occupation.

    The Academic Re-evaluation: Claiming Vygotsky and Luria

    In Russian academic circles (specifically psychology and neuroscience departments at Moscow State University), there is an ongoing effort to correct the historical record.

    • Russian scholars are increasingly highlighting how Spielrein’s “White Kindergarten” and her lectures in the 1920s directly shaped Lev Vygotsky (the father of Soviet developmental psychology) and Alexander Luria (the founder of modern neuropsychology).
    • By proving that Vygotsky and Luria integrated Spielrein’s ideas on child language and developmental psychology, Russian academia uses her to claim that the foundations of modern developmental psychology are fundamentally rooted in Russian/Soviet soil, rather than being purely Western exports.

    Despite this local pride, Spielrein’s actual core theories face a silent, structural glass barrier under Russia’s current ideological framework.

    • The Problem of Her Core Framework: Spielrein was a pioneer of feminist psychology and early psychoanalysis—frameworks that look directly at individual trauma, unconscious desires, and sexual dynamics. Classical psychoanalysis is still subtly viewed through a conservative state lens as a Western, hyper-individualistic, and socially corrosive philosophy.
    • The Suppression of Memory Archives: While Spielrein the person is honored, the systematic study of how she and her family were destroyed by the state is highly sensitive. Her three brilliant brothers were executed in Stalin’s Great Purge. Organizations like Memorial (the NGO dedicated to documenting Stalinist crimes), which actively unearthed the fates of families like the Spielreins, have been banned and criminalized in Russia. Therefore, Russia certainly honors her death at the hands of the Nazis, but heavily softens her persecution by the Soviet state.

    The Core Translation of Her Work

    In essence, modern Russia views Spielrein much like a museum artifact: she is celebrated as a “Great Russian Mind” who competed with and influenced the giants of the West (Jung and Freud). However, the radical, individual-liberating substance of her psychological theories remains largely unintegrated into the broader, state-sanctioned cultural narrative. She has been claimed by Russian history, but her deepest warnings—much like Jung’s and Arendt’s—are kept safely inside the glass case

    Sabina Spielrein in psychoanalytic history

    Compared to other sciences and professions, psychoanalysis appears quite open to the participation of women. This is especially true for the early period, as the way of the role of the analys and to the profession of psychoanalyst not very far and not once was unusual. In the history of psychoanalysis is Sabina Spielrein, however vain. In Ernest Jones’ standard work “Sigmund Freud” (1953) she is not recognized; in Peter Gay’s magnum opus, “Freud” (1987) she is only briefly mentioned in the context of Freud’s concept of the death instinct. Nancy Chodorow, dealing at least with the “contribution of women to the psychoanalytic movement and Theory” (1987), forgets her completely. Ellay Zaretskey drops her name four times, with Jung having a affair, together with Piage, as female psychoanalyst in Russia and one sentence about her death (without date and source).  The more the writer is leaning toward Freud, the more she is deliberately minimized, it seems. Almost like zhis is an act of repression, which is well-known defense mechanism according to Freud. Repression acts to keep information out of conscious awareness. However, as always memories about Spielrein don’t just disappear; they continue to influence the behavior of the psychoanalytic scene. Maybe they this consciously by forcing the unwanted information out of our awareness, which is known as suppression which is most likely. The last movie, “A Dangerous Method”,  makes  a romantic soft porn out of her story. After that movie many articles came up, but nobody seem to value her publications or even bother to read them.

    Conclusion

    There are many parts of Sabina Spielrein’s life that remain a mystery and there is continued controversy regarding specific dates and activities in her life .  She faced many obstacles, both because she was a woman working in a predominantly male profession and because she was Jewish during a period of violent antisemitism. Not only her tragic death cut short a life of promise, but it also seems even more her decision to move to the Freudian branch, which has been connected to the political left. Lured by the false promises of revolutionary  communism to Russian intellectuals  and her subsequent relocation to the USSR maybe by bad advice,  silenced her voice and relieved the scientific community of an inconvenient and outspoken competition.

    The psychoanalytic concept of repression is based on the axiom that an earlier event A suppressed by a later event B. Thus, event A obtains new meaning and now unfolds pathogenic effect. For this operation, the concept of ” deferred action ” was coined. The question of the displacement can be applied to the history of psychoanalysis itself. One could say: First, Sabina Spielrein was forgotten. There were plenty of reasons. She reminded the psychoanalytic movement inevitably on the traumatic break between Freud and Jung in 1913. Spielrein was also an independent and rather odd person who did not allow academic mandarins clamp their interests on her. She repeatedly kicked the structures of alpha males (and their coterie). She did not (want to) understand the rules of international psychoanalytic association, and with regard to questions of scientific priority did not bother with dangerous rivalries like Freud’s daughter Anna. As a ‘free electron’, she didn’t make it in the Western entrenched structures and moved to the even more dangerous settings of the aftermath of the Bolshevik revolution. Sabina Spielrein, even after her death, fell again victim to the severe struggle for affirmation of positions in psychoanalytical hierarchy or political viewpoints.

    Bibliography

    • Carotenuto, Aldo. A Secret Symmetry: Sabina Spielrein Between Jung and Freud. New York: 1982.
    • Kerr, John. A Most Dangerous Method: The Story of Jung, Freud, and Sabina Spielrein. New York: 1993.
    • Spielreins’s doctoral thesis and her famous publication “Die Destruktion als Ursache des Werdens” Jahrbuch für psychoanalytische und psychopathologische Forschungen IV. Band 1912 (JdP_IV_1912_1_SpielreinJung).
    • Sigmund Freud, Carl Gustav Jung Briefwechsel Freud / Jung Fischer Verlag 1974 (also available by Princeton University Press)
    • Henry Zvi Lothane, MD The real story of Sabina Spielrein: or fantasies vs. facts of a life
    • Karen Hall, Sabina Spielrein in the Jewish Women’s Archive
    • Ellay Zaretskey, Secrets of the Soul New York: 2004
    • Sabina Spielrein’s, “Destruction as the Cause of Coming into Being” – transformation as destruction for creation

    Selected Works

    Spielrein published thirty psychoanalytic papers in French and German. The majority of them have not yet been translated into English. Her two most significant works were her dissertation on schizophrenia, which contributed greatly to understanding the language of schizophrenics, and her second work, “Destruction as the Cause of Coming into Being”. Sabina Spielrein’s 1912 work, “Destruction as the Cause of Coming Into Being,” offers a profound, predictive framework for understanding collective, destructive, and renewal cycles . Her writings, which argue that “species-psyche” prioritizes collective transformation over individual ego, can be accessed through the Aphelis Archival PDF and Wiley Online Library. Furthermore, her correspondence with C.G. Jung, detailing the storage and activation of historical trauma in populations, is analyzed in SciELO. A comprehensive list of her publications is available through the Spielrein Association.

    As you can see after her reconciliation with her husband 1923 in Russia she wrote only one more paper.

    • “Über den psychologischen Inhalt eines Falles von Schizophrenie (Dementia Praecox).” Jahrbuch für psychoanalytische und psychopathologische Forschungen (1912): 3:329–400;
    • “Die Destruktion als Ursache des Werdens.” Johrbuch für psychoanalytische und psychopathologische Forschungen (1912) 4:465–503;
    • “Beiträge zur Kenntnis der Kindlichen Seele.” Zentralblatt für Psychoanalyse und Psychotherapie (1912) 3:57–72;
    • “Mutterliebe.” Imago (1912) 2:523–24; “Selbstbefriedigung in Fusssymbolik.” Zentralblatt für Psychoanalyse und Psychotherapie (1913) 3:263;
    • “Traum vom Vater Freudenreich.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychotherapie (1913) 1:484–486;
    • “Das unbewusste Träumen in Kuprins Zweikampf.” Imago (1913) 2:524–525; “Die Schwiegermutter.” Imago (1913) 2:589–591:
    • “Der vergessene Name.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse (1914) 2:383–384;
    • “Tiersymbolik and Phobie bei einem Knaben.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse (1914) 2:375–377;
    • “Zwei Mensesträume.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse (1914) 2:32–34;
    • “Ein unbewusster Richterspruch.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse (1915) 3:350;
    • “Die Äusserungen des Oedipuskomplexes im Kindersalter.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse (1916) 1:44–48;
    • “Das Schamgefühl bei Kindern.”Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse (1920) 6:157–158;
    • “Zur Frage der Entstehung und Entwicklung der Lautsprache.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse (1920) 6:401;
    • “Das Schwache Weib.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse (1920) 6:158;
    • “Verdraengte Munderotik.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse (1920) 6:361–362;
    • “Renatchens Menschenentstehungstheorie.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse (1920) 6:155–157;
    • “Russische Literatur.” Bericht über die Fortschritte der Psychoanalyse 1914–1919, Vienna: Internationaler Psychoanalytischer Verlag (1921);
    • “Schnellanalyse einer kindlichen Phobie.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse (1921) 7:473–474;
    • “Briefmarkentraum.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse, (1922) 8:342–343;
    • “Qui est l’auteur du crime?” Journal de Geneve 2 (January 15, 1922);
    • “Die Entstehung der kindlichen Worte Papa und Mama.” Imago (1922) 8:345–367;
    • “Schwiez.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse (1922) 8:234–235;
    • “Rêve et vision de étoiles filantes.” International Journal of Psycho-Analysis (1923) 4:129–132;
    • “Die drei Fragen.” Imago (1923) 9:260–263;
    • “L’automobile: Symbole de la puissance male.” International Journal of Psycho-Analysis (1923) 4:128;
    • “Ein Zuschauertypus.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse (1923) 9:210–211;
    • “Quelques analogies entre la pensée de l’enfant, celle de l’aphasique et la pensée subconsciente.” Archives de psychologie (1923) 18:306–322;
    • “Einige kleine Mitteilungen aus dem Kinderleben.” Zeitschrift für Psychoanalytische Pädagogik (1923) 2:95–99;
    • “Die Zeit im unterschwelligen Seelenleben.” Imago (1923) 9:300–317;

    During her time in the USSR and posthumous

    • “Kinderzeichnungen bei offenen und geschlossenen Augen. ” Imago (1931) 16:259–291;
    • “Destruction as the Cause of Coming into Being.” Journal of Analytical Psychology 39 (1994) 2:155–186;

    Film

    • “Ich hiess Sabina Spielrein (My name was Sabina Spielrein)”. Sweden: 2002.
    • “A Dangerous Method” by David Cronenberg: 2011

    Links

    Google

  • Personality models and Meta-Data – the Big Five (Eyes) and MBTI

    Personality models and Meta-Data – the Big Five (Eyes) and MBTI

    NSA

    This is a short snippet on Personality models, not an analysis but a warning to watch your friendly data collector near to you and your friendly government’s use of phobias. A paper published in the Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Social Computing, Behavioral-Cultural Modeling and Prediction shows that collected  communication and  social network trails, may turn out to be of highly personal character if not even of psychoanalytical use.

    Meta-Data prediction models are not perfect yet, but they have a huge potential. People with superior data mining tools can predict much more than just the personality. The science is not there yet, but a potential is to know the subject better than the subject understand him/her-self. Of course, also to predict what the subject will do in some patterned situations and to know the right reward and the right punishment for behavior for and against observer’s wishes. It is a dream resource for soft (and hard) totalitarian.

    A group of US and French researchers found that personality of the speaker on the phone could be reliably predicted by the way he or she makes calls. Their database was collected in the MIT Human Dynamics Lab in a year-and-a-half-long study from March 2010 to June 2011.

    What Metadata can do for you
    What Metadata can do for you

    The researchers, Yves-Alexandre de Montjoye, Jordi Quoidbach, Florent Robic and Alex Pentland used the 36 easy-to-obtain metadata elements, which fall into five categories:

    Basic phone use including the number of calls;

    Active user behaviors, as in the number of calls initiated, and the time it took the subject to answer a text;

    Location, or how far the subject moved, the number of places from which calls have been made, and other indicators of so-called radius of gyration;

    Regularity of calling routine;

    Diversity, defined as the ratio between the subject’s total number of contacts and the relative frequency at which he or she interacts with them.

    To figure out the results of the metadata analysis and to compare it with the personality, ‘hidden’ behind it, the organizational psychologists had determined psycho-types of 100 students, who participated in the survey (with a final sample of 69 people), and divided them also into five categories. They used major dimensions in the Big Five model (also called Five Factor Model) of personality, which also consists of conscientiousness, extraversion, neuroticism, openness to experience, and agreeableness.

    The Big Five Model

    Over the past few decades, personality psychology (mostly for marketing purpose) reached the consensus that the adjectives people use everywhere could be subsumed into five general constructs.  As far back as William McDougall (1932) noted that all personality could be measured by five traits: intellect, character, temperament, disposition, and temper. Dixon (1977) argued that terms used to describe thinking, feeling, and acting were found in all recorded human languages. Rieman (1987) attributed this universality to genetics (!)— the genes shared across races and cultures. Subsequently, Costa and McCrae’s five-factor model, measured by the NEO Personality Inventory (NEO-PI),  has been tested and its structure replicated in every language and country within which it has been studied. The five-factor model was actually one of two separate five-factor theoretical models.

    Big Five - No yin an yang - Freudian Ethic
    Big Five – No yin an yang – Freudian Ethic

    One model, popularized by Norman, and Digman purported that to understand and describe personality, one must have and use the terms contained within his/her language. Because personality was necessary for interpersonal interaction, personality traits would have to be in every language for people to coexist. The second model differs in the terms used for the five factors, but both had five similar measures for personality dimensions contrasting both sharply what are good and bad traits.

    The NEO-PI was associated with Costa and McCrae (1985). The first of its five factors was named Neuroticism or emotional stability. It included aspects of insecurity, tempermentalness, worrying, and self-consciousness, but it also included anxiety, anger, and depression, a factor measuring mental health in terms of normality/abnormality, not just some aspect of normal functioning or coping. Extroversion or Surgency formed the second factor. It was characterized by being friendly,sociable, and outgoing.  It also had a hint of value judgement in it as well, but seemed generally more accepted than the neuroticism factor. Openness included being daring, original, open-minded, and imaginative. It involved being accepting of fantasies, feelings, and values. Agreeableness was the fourth factor. It was often contrasted with antagonism, which was characterized by narcissism, perfectionism, and arrogance. Agreeableness included aspects of trust versus skepticism and sympathy versus stubborn uncooperativeness. Factor five, termed Conscientiousness, had also been contrasted with undirectedness. Amelang and Borkenau titled this factor self-control versus impulsivity (!). Some called it superego strength as in an individual’s abilities in persevering, striving for excellence, hard working, and exerting effort with a purposeful direction.

    The Big Five (v.s. the MBTI) is one of marketing, its not help you to understand yourself, but others to benchmark you against a desired standard behavioral set.

    These factors are very broad and inclusive, but almost stipulate a Freudian ethic. They assumed that all human could be categorized under these five headings – and measure in a way just adaption to the society. To me, the Big Five, is a tool how good you function in the “rat race” or as consumer. To correct this, there’s growing support for a HEXACO model of personality that adds a sixth trait: honesty-humility.

    C. G. Jung’s typology and the MBTI Model

    Example
    Example

    Based on C. G. Jung’s typology [Jung, 1921], people can be classified using four mental functions sensing, intuition, thinking and feeling together with the attitude (extraversion-introversion). An extrovert deals more with the objective whereas an introvert relies more with the subjective – C.G. Jung is quite clear that both the objective and the subjective represent facts and reality. The direction points to the source of energy that feeds the dominant mental function. An extrovert’s source of energy is mainly found in the outside world, whereas an Introvert’s source of energy is mainly found in his or her inner world. C. G. Jung’s classification scheme has been used quite successfully from individuals (I’ve written here) as well in the workplace (see here). The unconscious layer, Carl Jung’s analytical psychology model provides, maps to the structures of the organizational or political conscious and unconscious which parallel what Jung conceived as the architecture of the individual psyche.

    1. Attitude Extravert: Outer-directed, need for sociability, chooses people as a source of energy, often action-oriented.
    2. Attitude Introvert: Inner-directed, need for privacy and space; chooses solitude to recover energy, often reflective.
    1. Thinking function: Logical, analyses (thus rational) cause & effect relations, cool, distant,frank, questioning.
    2. Feeling function: Valuing positively or negatively. (thus rational and not the same as the word used in emotion)
    3. Sensing function: Sensory, oriented toward the body and senses, detailed, concrete, present.
    4. Intuitive function: Sees many possibilities in situations, goes with hunches not details, sometimes not present. The function that is opposite to sensation. Intuition is a perception of realities that are not known to consciousness, and that come via the unconscious.

    One rarely finds pure types and originally with Jung obviously there were  8 combinations with ones primary function but ones  secondary function may be developed (and rarely the third and forth). The extroverted thinking person tends to be tied to facts, may believe his ideas represent absolute truth and that “the ends justify the means”dislikes and fears the irrational. Introverted thinking person is interested not in facts but ideas. Extroverted feeling person often seems to be well adjusted, charming, concerned with personal relationships. Introverted feeling type are not easily adaptable and may express self in music, poetry, religion. Extroverted sensing type– the object arousing the sensation is the important thing. Introverted sensing types have trouble expressing themselves. Extroverted Intuitive lives see possibilities as important. Last, the Introverted intuitive is concerned with the collective unconscious and has visions or revelations of religious or cosmic nature.

    Mapping The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) to the Big Five

    The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) dimensions (Extraversion-Introversion; Sensation-Intuition; Thinking-Feeling; and Judging-Perceiving), based on C.G. Jung formed a tight 4-factor model similar to that of Costa and McCrae’s Big Five model for openness, conscientiousness, agreeableness, extraversion.

    My thoughts on the Big Five. I find it hard to not look at Openness and neuroticism as a dichotomy. How can we be both open and neurotic at the same time?

    All in all, the big 5 uses 5 traits, and doesn’t link them together, where as the MBTI uses 8, and links them together. The MBTI just gives more information, however, Big 5 is also more static, and can definitely be used at the same time as MBTI.  Jungian’s, however, don’t recognize that just four letters do justice to anyone’s identity for the whole life. Bad leaders, consultants, counselors, coaches, and teachers, had been delivering this message,  omitting  C.G. Jung’s view of individuation – i.e. that healthy persons are in control of their four functions and grow to manipulate MBTI to money making personality tests.  To make matter worse,  the Big five seem to judge only  one alternative dimension as desirable (unlike  C.G. Jung did). I don’t subscribe to this.

    DESCRIPTION HERE
    DESCRIPTION HERE


    Extraversion – people who tend to seek stimulation in the company of others, who are outgoing and energetic; I fail to see why the Big Five Model changes the “o” into an “a”….  E of course equals the MBTI E with the implicit assumption that introverts are bad .

    Agreeableness – sensing, compassionate and cooperative people (easy to manipulate however); Agreeableness, I’d say it may also be Fe , not only F.

    Openness – and creative ones, who are open to feelings (intellectually less curious, however); You might recall that thinking and feeling are rational functions to C.G. Jung and to him indeed feeling means either accept or reject. So Openness equals to F, without a mix of N or P, but not with 100% correlations.

    Conscientiousness – self-disciplined and judging people, who are eager for success ( not perceiving others); Conscientiousness  seems like a sure J.

    I think the neurotic scale shows us the probability that we are utilizing shadow survival functions. Neuroticism in big 5 is the only scale that doesn’t correlate with MBTI directly. The fifth dimension – neuroticism – will tell which button to press of anxiety, moodiness, worry, envy, and jealousy. Neuroticism is a risk factor for the “internalizing” mental disorders such as phobia, depression and other anxiety disorders, all of which are traditionally called neuroses but become more and more political terms. Furthermore MBTI has N and F in I and E attitude, while Big Five just mixes the both in one, and the rating scales aren’t 100% the same, like 40% openness might still come out as N in MBTI test.

    Conclusion

    Add personalty tests with capabilities to obtain and crunch your data with a big data warehouse for your Twitter, email and Facebook, not to mention your browsing history or Amazon preferences , than psychoanalysis become truly affordable for everybody. Interested will check on your conscientiousness and your eagerness for success like for credit rating or how you do on neuroticism in respect to xyz-phobia.

  • History of Time I: The face of God from ancient cultures to the big bang.

    History of Time I: The face of God from ancient cultures to the big bang.

    primordal sinThe history of time reflects culture – interconnecting temporal powers, religion and science. For millenniums priest were gatekeeper of time and calendar(s). Now scientists have taken over. Today we are able to contemplate beyond the creation of time, even beyond the big bang. I got the idea to this essay after I read a  book, titled… you guessed it… “The Face of God” (Le Visage de Dieu) while I struggled writing a long article “The history of time” from a historical and religious view. After I read the book, I decided to break my monster article in pieces and introduce them with this essay. So this is the first of a series “History of Time” which explores concepts of time and calendars over the last 5000 years.

    Most people today avoid the sacred dimension of time as a subject. They may fear past and future – and mortality. Perhaps they have never really thought through meaning of time. Einstein’s outspokenness on his religious attitude was rare. Today religion (and science) are attacked both by post-modern philosophers, “social scientists” claiming all truths are relative and by creationists claiming everything was created just by chance. Under these circumstances, there are good reasons why most scientists avoid all possibility of confusion with religion by never using terms suggestive of divinity. But the loss is that there is no way to understand: we are actually answering questions today whose had been asked by priests and philosophers before.  What human action could be more sacred than that?

    As we will there is a language of the sacred dimension of time and my essays (touching all major cultures) will follow a certain structure.

    • The sacred language of time
    • The worldly language of time
    • The history of time – Measurement and Calendars

    The article gives the upcoming  structure as interplay of science, anthropology and religion. Many thinkers nowadays see theistic arguments as just a quick, lazy, irrational short-cut, though of course this is not necessarily the case; there are many smart, thoughtful, careful thinkers who believe in God – not necessarily in religious institutions.

    The face of God – cosmology meets meta-physics

    We live in political depressing feudal new world order, however, physics today quite successfully attempts to answer metaphysical questions:

    • What shape has our universe and where are its borders?
    • Why is it so exactly fine tuned, like defined by an meta-order?
    • When and how was time and the world was created?
    • When and how will be destroyed or is it fluctuating?
    • What was before creation of time?

    Cosmology became an  empirical and exact science, and it has to be noted that some of its answers proof Church fathers as Augustine right.

    The frontiers of contemporary time

    Face of God.  This is the furthest thing we can see.
    Face of God. This is the furthest thing we can see.

    Three  scientists in 1948 suggested in the famous alpha-beta-gamma report (according to their initials) that billion years ago, the cosmic background radiation of the big bang spreading itself thin must have become low-energy microwaves far colder than ice, later identified at 2.73 degrees above absolute zero as smooth cosmic background radiation. Our universe, however is awfully lumpy, broken up into people, planets, stars, galaxies, clusters of galaxies, and giant walls of superclusters surrounding giant voids.  People had been probing the cosmic background radiation for 30 years, but no one had detected any deviation from absolute smoothness until 1992 variations in temperature measured in millionths of a degree were detected. These minuscule differences show the ripples in spacetime, where matter first began to clump gravitationally about 10,000 years after the Big Bang. Radiation from regions of higher density expended more energy trying to escape a deeper gravitational well and therefore appeared slightly cooler than average   were chartered in oval shaped eggs in shades of pink and blue decorate Smoot’s office, depicting the pattern of temperature fluctuations across the heavens. As bright and gay as enormous Easter eggs.

    Time before time was created

    We now can see back up to 380 000 years before the big bang which occurred 13.7 Billion years ago. We enter know metaphysics area. The universe was created from blue print of fine tuned informational pattern (logos the word) and well understood particle physics.

    John 1:1

    en Archêi ên ho Logos – in the beginning was the word; kai ho Logos ên pros ton Theon – and the word came to god; kai Theos ên ho Logos – God himself was the word

    It is a challenge to translate the greek word logos correctly in a single contemporary word. Logos is derived from lego, “say or speak” whose root leg means “plan, collect“. For the Greeks speaking was  “give from an array of words” or the “combining the thoughts.”

    We conclude today the universe(space) and time has been created 10-43 seconds after time 0 in a flash of light out of singularity but not ex-nihilo, like written in the Genesis. But where has been god – inside or outside of the universe? An what was he and what was before time?

    Physics talks about the KMS-state in the whole universe and contemplates time was defined mathematically complex, oscillating between its real and imaginary component. Remember a complex number is a number that can be expressed in the form a + bi, where a and b are real numbers and i is the imaginary unit, which satisfies the equation i2 = −1.

    So there there are three forms of time in cosmology:

    • Time connected with energy – our real physical time – mathematically an instance of an abstract object or with C.G. Jung an Archetype;
    • Time connect with information (imaginary energy) instead with real energy – frozen imaginary time – mathematically an abstract object or with C.G. Jung an archetype per-se;
    • The imaginary time is part of the complex time  before the big bang  and out of our physical scope  – true meta-physical ;

    Es werde Licht thus transforms logos i.e. information (imaginary energy) to real energy and imaginary time to real time – from divine patterns.

    Divine patterns and theism

    Theist as Richard Swinburne and Philip L. Quinn that the specific content of the scientifically most fundamental laws of nature, including the constants they contain, requires supra-scientific explanation or a reconciliation between science and religion. The old-fashioned point of view tend to disbelieve in any religious component to the workings of the universe. Materialism asserts that a complete description of nature consists of an understanding of the structures of which it is comprised together with the patterns which those structures follow, while theism insists on the need for a conscious God who somehow rises above those patterns. Materialist have put their hope to mechanical, evolutionary an biological models stayed shy of the big bang. Within this cosmology, there are two possible roads to reconciliation between science and religion. One is to claim that science and religion are not incompatible because they speak to completely distinct sets of questions, and hence never come into conflict. The other is to assert that thinking scientifically does not lead to rejection of theism, but in fact that religious questions can answered in a similar way than cosmology does.

    The essence of materialism is to model the world as a formal system, which is both unambiguous and complete as a description of reality. A materialist model may be said to consist of four elements. First, we model the world as some formal (mathematical) structure.  Second, this structure exhibits patterns (the ”laws of nature”). Third, we need boundary conditions which specify the specific realization of the pattern. Finally, we need a way to relate this formal system to the world we see: an ”interpretation.”

    The reader might worry that we are glossing over very subtle and important issues in the philosophy of science; they would be correct, but needn’t worry. Philosophy of science becomes difficult when we attempt to describe the relationship of the formalism to the world (the interpretation), as well as how we invent and choose between theories. But the idea that we are trying, in principle, to model the world as a formal system is fairly uncontroversial.

    The materialist thesis (before the big bang) was simply: that’s all there is to the world. With Freud it was  you eat, copulate and died. Defining theism is more difficult  and its subtlety has therefore been transferred to the task of defining ”God.” When I say that God I also have in mind the pantheistic god. In my view, neither cosmology nor theism is logically impossible, but a pure materialism alien to “home religious” as defined by C. G.Jung. This is most evident if we look at the history of time.

    The sacred language of time

    What is time

    Two opposite concepts of time need to be introduced – the  understanding of linear time  (time has a beginning and and end – predominately in Western civilizations) contrary to revolving and cyclist time (predominately in Eastern civilizations). With linear calendars the question arises when time starts. Cultures differ have different ways of putting value at, organizing and using time.

    When did the universe begin?

    Time was either seen infinite beyond creation or a property of our world – i.e. created together with the world. Ancient myth, religions, humanistic philosophers like Kant and now contemporary science in particular cosmology, a fast growing discipline of astrophysics, converge at the latter thesis – at the language of sacred dimension of time.

    How did the universe begin (Creation myth)?

    Creation
    Creation

    Creation myths define how the Earth itself was created, along with the universe, heavens, hell, people, and creatures that exist today. Genesis of Christian mythology, for instance, tells the story of how the single deity God spoke and formed everything. The Genesis and the Book of the Dead of Egypt share the similar ideas of life and afterlife. Others, like the Japanese and Iroquois creation myths, claim the Earth was once covered entirely of water before land was formed.  Through studies such as comparative mythology, researchers and philosophers have discovered hundreds of parallels between the myths that make up every culture, including their creation myths. As most are deeply rooted in religion, comparisons based on geographic area, themes, and similar story lines emerge as religions are born and merge. C.G. Jung recognized these similarities and states,  It is possible to correlate creation myths of Zen-Buddhism and Christianity, Hinduism and Islam, Confucianism and Hinduism, and polytheistic Greek and Roman state religions. They compare the messianic religions: Christianity, Islam and Judaism; the enlightenment religions, including Buddhism, Hinduism, Sikhism, and Jainism; and the pantheistic religions, encompassing a large group of with Taoism, Confucianism, and Shinto. In all of them exists the basic idea of chaos before creation, and god(s) to form space and time and as such life.  Another common element in some myths is a tree of life that connect connects the different realms of the universe together, often referred to as a axis mundi or cosmic channel.

    One of the most notable comparisons exists between the Genesis of the Christian religion and the Enuma Elish of Babylonian descent a culture with an highly developed astronomy. Yaw-he or Marduk, are in both myths divine spirits that coexist independent with cosmic matter and are independent of it. In each, the universe is enveloped in darkness. Then light emanates from the gods of both creation myths. They create a firmament –  just like today in modern cosmology.  The creation myth formed by the Egyptians and that formed by the Chinese also share common aspects. The most popular Egyptian creation myth centers around life stemming from an cosmic egg. Different sources refer also to the solar disk in Egyptian, Nordic, Germanic, Greek & Vedic tradition,

    As C.G. Jung noted, Archetypes an Symbols have been an integral element of the lives of all people through either non-spiritual or spiritual means. From what we consider the beginning of humanity to today, myths have been used to educate people why everything happens or how everything came into being. The comparison of myths has emerged as popular archetypes in C.G. Jungs writing. The creation myths, in particular, provide examples of borrowed symbols and common beliefs which persist throughout history. With these parallels, humanity can better understand earlier cultures and document how mythologies interrelate over time.

    Natural and supernatural powers

    Light and Darkness were first taken as granted like anything in nature. Duration created time and with it the observation of the stunning regularity of sun, moon and stars, which lead to the concept of future and past.  Our understanding of time shapes our understanding of god, of creation and of the universe. Of course the opposite also is true.

    Temporal powers

    With time the primordial sin came to the world and who gained knowledge of time became priest, emperor and gods. In ancient times, the archetype of the magician or priest, the loving god, the king and the warrior typically were combined in the god-emperor. As we will see also temporal rulers (kings, pharaohs, popes or revolutionaries) always had control over worldly calenders and the priest over sacred (and secret) calendars.

    Future and Past

    With calendars, priest and rulers could not only organize the past, but also plan (and claim to predict) the future. It became possible to calculate the time between two events, to know sacred days or just to “measure in advance”, when the flooding of the Nile or the tax payment is due. That has been diverse and indispensable role from the early agricultural societies, trade industrialization up to the today’s complex global world.

    What is after human life ends?

    Human limited time, i.e. the painful knowledge of mortality led to the question  of what might be after life, which was answered by religions with supernaturals (gods and spirits) as masters of time and for mortals paradise, hell, rebirth or nirvana or ancestor spirits.

    How will the universe end

    Christian belief tells us,that we lost immortality by eating the fruit of knowledge and that redemption of Jesus promises resurrection and living forever again.

    The worldly (temporal) language of time

    Time and Mankind

    Sometimes during the last 2.5 million years, mankind became conscious of the I (Ego in an Jungian Sense). With this followed the consciousnesses of time, of “now and then”, of synchronicity and duration.  This was the begin of subjective (individual) time and of course with the human memory came the past and flow of time.

    Time and Language

    The language transcended the limitation of the direct experience and opened the path to the future like a linear “time arrow”. With language came regularity, structure and abstraction. From “here and now” mankind went to the collective past (history) to individual and future (civilization).

    Time and Culture

    The modern time conception of Westerners is strong and they really cherish (their life-) time and ironically waste it with cheap distractions. In contemporary Europe, where more and more people have no children at all and to a high degree lost connection to any religion, time becomes predominantly subjective and abstract beyond their little life span. In a way Westerners became Rousseau’s innocent savages in there little consumer paradise (or hell).

    So our concept of time also has to do what we think of our after-life.

    Time and religion

    Today we miss the wisdom of the spirituality. In Christianity there is chronos and kairos. Both are Greek words which mean time, but they imply different things. Chronos refers to minutes and seconds. It refers to time as a measurable resource. Kairos is the word used for time in Ephesians 5:16). kairos means an appointed time, an opportune moment, or a due season (like in Taoism the right moment to act).

    Time and psychology

    C.G. Jung had special understanding of time what he called “temporally coincident occurrences of acausal events” or  “meaningful coincidence” and “acausal parallelism in which archetypes and the collective unconscious are governing a dynamic that underlies the whole of human experience and history — social, emotional, psychological, and spiritual.

    Synchronicity does not admit causality in the analogy between terrestrial events and astrological constellations … What astrology can establish are the analogous events, but not that either series is the cause or the effect of the other. (For instance, the same constellation may at one time signify a catastrophe and at another time, in the same case, a cold in the head.) … In any case, astrology occupies a unique and special position among the intuitive methods… I have observed many cases where a well-defined psychological phase, or an analogous event, was accompanied by a transit (particularly when Saturn and Uranus were affected). – Carl G. Jung

    Jung and the quantum physicist Pauli believed, events like this occur too often enough to be only meaningless coincidence. Jung noted taking as usual phenomenological stance, while it would be “absurd” to consider the conjunction of dream material and life events to be causal, “it is wise to consider the fact that [these coincidences] do happen…The East…considers coincidences as the reliable basis of the world rather than causality. Synchronism is the prejudice of the East; causality is the modern prejudice of the West.”

    Oh yes, there was a fall, a great big one.  The ancients, our forefathers and mothers, knew right away that something horrible had happened. This was the big bang, the creation of time, and the second mankind understanding of is. Thus Adam and Eve myth  became like God.  Nietzsche, who understood all this, said Christianity closed the door to mass nihilism and decay. To be healed by the words Good and Evil.  Christ was the greatest poet who ever lived. He was murdered because he understood all this. Christ understood this and said so; the kingdom is here within us. This is the meaning of religion as o fpsychology is man’s attempt to free himself from linear time.

    Time and Society

    Even hunters and gathers (at least in a harsh climate) needed to be aware of time. The resulting calendars have been an integral part of different cultures. But even more farmers and traders. Warrior societies need less accurate time than farmers. The first Roman calendar became a mess before fixed by Julius Caesar (with a little help of the Egypt solar calendar). The great French philosopher Voltaire once quipped in hindsight: “The Romans emperors won all the battles but they did not know when”.

    Time and economy

    Since the beginning of mankind time comes from observation of nature. In any culture, however, the task of the calendar was not only limited to the counting of days. Each date should be assigned to the repeating pattern in nature.  Without the ability to plan the time by days, weeks, months and years, agriculture, civil administration and a differentiated role based economies would have been impossible . Even today there are still new applications – especially with the financial and interest experts with perverse micro-trading.

    Time and Mathematics

    The Athenian law courts – according to Plato’s Apology – had water-clocks: if you couldn’t prove your case before the water-clock stopped dripping, you couldn’t prove your case. History, of course, has time-hooks. It can be said, however that the world of mathematics exists in an eternal present, a state in which neither the past nor the future have any meaning. Thus, because mathematics has no interest in the time dimension, there is also in mathematics no meaning to the question of reason. The area which mathematics does address is the clarification of relationships between various objects: how they connect with each other. This world, although dealing with relationships between stable and changing things, is entirely fundamental with the major dimensions of time – duration (present) and regularity of reoccurring events (past and future).

    Time and Astronomy

    Ever since man first noticed the regularity in the movement of the Sun and the stars, astronomers have wondered about duration and measured time by the Sun, the Moon and the Stars. As the sun moves across the sky, shadows change in direction and length. Calendar algorithms used natures repeating events the sun, month, moon phases and other astronomical information.They were commonplace, long before watches. Calendar algorithms also allowed the inclusion of sacred (or cursed days) and the number of days, although the week had nothing to do with the movement of the stars.

    Time and Nature

    The earliest natural events to be recognized were in the heavens, but during the course of the year there were many other events that indicated significant changes in the environment. Seasonal winds and rains, the flooding of rivers, the flowering of trees and plants, and the breeding cycles or migration of animals and birds, all led to natural divisions of the year, and further observation and local customs led to the recognition of the seasons.

    Time and Science

    What “cosmological results” suggest to some “divine inference”? Simply put: the anthropic principle, or more precisely, the fine tuning of the physical laws. In a nutshell – the fact that many/most of the fundamental properties of the universe, from the charge of the electron to the speed of light, and the total content and rate of expansion of the universe have values that could not have been even slightly different if life, intelligence, and consciousness, like humans and other such creatures, were to exist. Needless to say, many have concluded that something must behind such “fine tuning” like “cosmic code” or divine DNA.

    Creation

    bigbangI want to come back to the creation myths. In 1992 when astronomer George Smoot, the father of the COBE (Cosmic Background Explorer) satellite  announced the discovery of patterns in the heat background radiation still arriving from the Big Bang, he said it was “like seeing the face of God.” He took a lot of secular sneering for this remark from colleagues.

    The quantum theory was spiritually unacceptable to Einstein as its ultimate nature of reality was randomness. “The [quantum] theory yields much,” he wrote to quantum physicist Max Born in 1926, “but it hardly brings us close to the secrets of the Ancient One. In any case, I am convinced that God does not play dice.”  And he was right, today we now that the creation of our universe follows regular pattern and some physical constants must have a certain value – or we would not exists. Independent formulated theories by Alan Guth (MIT) and before by Russian physicist Andrei Linde, holds that the universe began in the expanding fireball of the big bang and then inflated.Quantum fluctuations-hot, spots-arose.The discovery of the microwave whisper, by Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson of AT&T’s Bell Labs in 1964, just about proved that the universe began in a big bang. Hawkins today agrees with church father Augustine the time and space, the world was created together with time in a flash of light. Trouble was, the microwave sea seemed 1964 incredibly smooth. If energy and matter are spread across the heavens so evenly, how could particles ever have clumped together into galaxies? COBE saw almost undetectable temperature fluctuations.

    1992 astrophysicist George Smoot of the Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory announced that they had discovered those primordial wrinkles, floating at the very beginning of time. Wispy tendrils, up to 59 billion trillion miles across, are the most gigantic and the most ancient structures ever seen.

    Sacred dimensions

    Creation myths, from Egypt to the Old Testament’s six days of genesis created the archetypes of time, a flash of light from a singularity of cosmos inflating so wildly that, faster than an eye blink, a blob smaller than a proton grew as big as today’s entire visible universe. This infant created ripples of energy in the fabric of its space. The ripples stretching as the universe expanded and created the sparkling patterns energy and matter which clustered to stars and galaxies of our night sky. The astounding message is that  creation myths might be right. Smoot said: “human beings have the audacity to conceive a theory of creation.” Really? The priests of ancient cultures may just have gotten their spirituality right. In the Beginning…

    There is the story of the Rabbi who dutifully and concerned asked Einstein in which kind of God, then, did Einstein believe in? “I believe in Spinoza’s God who reveals himself in the harmony of all that exists, but not in a God who concerns himself with the fate and actions of human beings.”  The was Einstein’s faith, which at least not entirely anti-spiritual.

    A somewhat more modest astrophysicist, whose theory had correctly predicted the discovery of the “divine structures”, Joel Primack was quoted as calling those ripples 380 000 years after the Big Bang, “the handwriting of God.” Are these references to the creator sacrilegious or legitimate interpretations? Either way, they are part of a search that began with the first high cultures in Mesopotamia — the search for language to communicate the sacred dimension of time.

    The history of time – Measurement and Calendars

    This will be covered in a series of essays covering all major civilizations and will follow the same structure.

    • The sacred dimensions of their understanding time
    • The worldly usage of their understanding time
    • The manifestations in time measurement and calendars

    Conclusion

    Aft all what I understood, we can interpret space and time as a sort of secret encoded message that science has begun to encipher long after spiritual systems and human intuition (be it by definition of Immanuel Kant or C.G. Jung had the ability to acquire this knowledge without inference of reason or experiment. C.G. Jung’s introverted intuitive types were likely mystics, prophets, or seers struggling between protecting their visions and making their ideas comprehensible but reasonably persuasive—a necessity for their visions (or religions) to foster.

    • “The exact Science in Antiquity”  O. Neugebauer, Dover Edition 1989
    • “Le visage de Dieu“, 2010 Igor and Grichka Bogdanov
    •  “Symbole der Wandlung” C.G. Jung GW , 1952 Rascher Zürich
    • “Universalgeschichte der Zeit” Hans Lenz, 2005 Marix Verlag.
    • “Cosmos An illustrated History of Astronomy and Cosmology”. John North 2008

    Appendix review of “Le visage de Dieu”

    The book is just that good, what can I say. From the scientific point of view, it stays loyal to the physics and everything as we now understand it, within its usual debates. The rest is just philosophical and metaphysical discussion and interpretation on meaning and direction in the Universe and Everything. They take a step, after reaching the limits of what science can explain, and try to fit it all in a spiritual vision of creation. Faith is a very popular topic of discussion in many cultures including the French, and this book expresses itself and its opinion very elegantly, while on the subject of scientific creation itself I might add, and delivering it all in a language any man can understand.
    They authors claim (correctly, just very much like C.G. Jung) that at the limits of where science can study, observe and verify, metaphysics can take over, continue the story, and they do it masterfully. What they interpret as divine inference any scientist can take as just another law/equation yet to be explain. The  book has been given unprecedented exposure in the French media, especially considering its overt spiritual tone. Indeed, the Bogdanov twins state clearly that they believe that the Creator conclusion is inescapable from the results of modern Cosmology. They themselves are not particularly religious, in the sense that they do not relate to any specific affiliation, but clearly are convinced of on the divine inference. What “cosmological results” are they basing themselves on to make that “divine inference”? Simply put: the anthropic principle, or more precisely, the fine tuning of the physical laws. In a nutshell – the fact that many/most of the fundamental properties of the universe, from the charge of the electron to the speed of light, and the total content and rate of expansion of the universe have values that could not have been even slightly different if life, intelligence, and consciousness, like humans and other such creatures, were to exist. Needless to say, many have concluded that something must behind such “fine tuning” like “cosmic code” or divine DNA. Three  famous scientists have endorsed the book by writing a preface and two post-faces:  Robert Wilson, who (with Arno Penzias) discovered the microwave cosmological background in the 60’s and received the Nobel Prize in 1978; John Mather, who (with George Smoot) in 2006 received the Nobel Prize for the variations they found in the microwave cosmological background, which Smoot likened to “seeing the face of God”; Jim Peebles, a renowned cosmologist who has received half a dozen medals, awards, and honors (though not the Nobel Prize).

    Interesting enough, this book has infuriated atheist and anti-christian hate reviews. Usually a good sign , the  so called “intelligentsia”, especially in Europe, do not like the divine inference. The answer to why is far from trivial, but it has to do with sociology-historical reasons as much as political reasons or just spiritual deafness.

    1:1 en Archêi ên ho Logos
    im Ursprung ging der Sinn auf
    kai ho Logos ên pros ton Theonund der Sinn erschloß sich dem Gott
     kai Theos ên ho Logosund Gott selbst war der Sinn

  • Shakespeare’s “Macbeth” from a Jungian view

    Shakespeare’s “Macbeth” from a Jungian view

    when they all know the good as good, there arises the recognition of evil.
    When they all know the good as good, there arises the recognition of evil.

    This article explores the psychological underpinnings of  Shakespeare’s “Macbeth” from a Jungian view. Carl Jung left a great deal of ambiguity surrounding his work. He understood, as long as there have been men and they have lived, they have all felt this tragic ambiguity and everybody must accept his or her “Shadow” during the individuation process. Ambiguity between good an evil, and a failed individuation is the core theme in the tragedy Macbeth: “Fair is foul, and foul is fair” say the three witches in the beginning of the play and this paradox is touched again by Macbeth: “So foul and fair a day I have not seen”. The enemy and death is “foul” – bad – but the outcome of the battle is “fair” – good, only because he has won.So the play Macbeth is about the evil, but as we see mostly the evil in us, and this evil is first impersonated by the witches. That is why Macbeth is also called the “Scottish play” by the superstitious theater folk. The play has gotten a reputation for being bad luck in terms of productions and those who act in it, and so it is referred from them to as “the Scottish play” to avoid naming it. The play is about the good consumed by the evil. However, Tao says Tao is eternal and so are the two principles Yang and Yin, so that good and evil must be eternal, as necessary elements of our world.

    Secularism, particularly relativism has tried to blur the line between good and evil where belief systems and philosophies used different approaches to mask the ambiguity between “evil and good”.  Dualistic has the view that the world consists of or is explicable as those two fundamental entities. It is God, love, death, suffering and infinity that open us to the non-dualistic mind, or contemplation. Dualism means eliminating everything that is not like you (or projecting all your rejected attributes to others). Lao-Tse and Jesus were masters of non-dualistic thinking. The Jungian System is a fine example of an non-dualistic psychology : the more inflated your self-image (Ego), the bigger your shadow will be. Macbeth looses his soul (his Self) failing to differentiate between Persona and his inflated Ego and overwhelmed by his shadow and his anima utilized by the ambitious Lady Macbeth. 

    Jung’s vastly varying influences have helped shape a psychology that has influenced a great many scholars, theorists, psychologists, and artists of various specialties. While still maintaining an empirical stance Carl Gustav Jung has taken the influential elements of literature, symbolism, religion, and the alchemy and has formed these raw, primordial factors into a unparalleled  psychoanalytic system. Jung’s view of literature was ambivalent. He was fascinated by Nietzsche, and lectured on Nietzsche’s Zarathustra, Besides of German literature C. G. Jung appears to have been influenced by Shakespeare. In particular Jung was interested in the mythic and archaic elements in literature. Hermann Hesse’s novel Demian was inspired by Jung’s theory of individuation whereas Macbeth seems to be the prototype of a failure to achieve successful ego-individuation.

    The play Macbeth

    title_macbeth
    title_macbeth

    Jung found literature to be a psychological process which includes the process of materials being “drawn from man’s conscious life; and the visionary dealing with primordial images that transcend human understanding.” Jung found that the archetypal symbols he worked with could, quite naturally, be found in the works of various ages. “It is to be expected… that the poet will turn to these mythological images to give suitable expression to his own experiences.”

    Macbeth, when you analyze it, is a psychological battle between good and evil, and between evil ambition and order. Darkness is a symbol of the characters forgetting all about honor or goodness. The play demands that the audience think about how we make excuses in our life to pursue false ambitions that are wrong. Macbeth makes this mistake and ultimately it leads to his death. Darkness in Macbeth is a key theme. The play begins with the brief appearance of a trio of witches and then moves to a military camp, where the Scottish King Duncan hears the news that his generals, Macbeth and Banquo, have defeated two separate invading armies—one from Ireland, led by the rebel Macdonwald, and one from Norway. Macbeth and Banquo encounter the witches who prophesy that Macbeth will be made thane (a rank of Scottish nobility) of Cawdor and eventually King of Scotland. Macbeth and Banquo treat their prophecies skeptically until some of King Duncan’s men come to thank the two generals for their victories in battle and to tell Macbeth that he has indeed been named thane of Cawdor. Macbeth is intrigued by the possibility that the remainder of the witches’ prophecy—that he will be crowned king—might be true, but he is uncertain what to expect. It remins me a little bit of Wagners Rhinemaidens, who have a magical gold treasures with magical powers. Alberich an ugly dwarf, trys to score on them but they laugh at him. So he robs their treasure with  the ring (the key to power and wealth). To do this, he must renounce love. I think Macbeth never could love, neither himself nor others.

     Lady Macbeth suffers none of her husband’s uncertainty. She desires the kingship for him and wants him to murder Duncan in order to obtain it. When Macbeth arrives at Inverness, she overrides all of her husband’s objections and persuades him to kill the king that very night. He and Lady Macbeth plan to get Duncan’s two chamberlains drunk so they will blame the murder on the chamberlains. While Duncan is asleep, Macbeth stabs him, despite his doubts and a number of supernatural portents, including a vision of a bloody dagger. When Duncan’s death is discovered the next morning, Macbeth kills the chamberlains—ostensibly out of rage at their crime—and easily assumes the kingship. Duncan’s sons Malcolm and Donalbain flee to England and Ireland, respectively, fearing that whoever killed

    C_G_JUNG_FEMALE_ARCHETYPES
    C_G_JUNG_MALE_FEMALE_ARCHETYPES

    Duncan desires their demise as well. Fearful of the witches’ prophecy that Banquo’s heirs will seize the throne, Macbeth hires a group of murderers to kill Banquo and his son Fleance. They ambush Banquo on his way to a royal feast, but they fail to kill Fleance, who escapes into the night. Macbeth becomes furious: as long as Fleance is alive, he fears that his power remains insecure. At the feast that night, Banquo’s ghost visits Macbeth. When he sees the ghost, Macbeth raves fearfully, startling his guests, who include most of the great Scottish nobility causing Macbeth’s kingship to incite increasing resistance from his nobles and subjects. Frightened, Macbeth goes to visit the witches in their cavern. There, they show him a sequence of demons and spirits who present him with further prophecies: he must beware of Macduff, a Scottish nobleman who opposed Macbeth’s accession to the throne. Macbeth orders that Macduff’s castle be seized and, most cruelly, that Lady Macduff and her children be murdered. It should be clear by now, that Macbeth represents the archetypes of weak king and becomes a cruel sadistic warrior, whereas Lady Macbeth seems to own foremost frigid witch qualities.

    When news of his family’s execution reaches Macduff in England, he is stricken with grief and takes revenge and with Prince Malcolm, Duncan’s son, and the support of the Scottish nobles, who are appalled and frightened by Macbeth’s tyrannical and murderous behavior. Lady Macbeth, meanwhile, becomes plagued with fits of sleepwalker in which she bemoans what she believes to be bloodstains on her hands. Before Macbeth’s opponents arrive, Macbeth receives news that she has killed herself, causing him to sink into a deep and pessimistic despair.

    He is struck numb with fear, however, when he learns that the English army is advancing on Dunsinane shielded with boughs cut from Birnam Wood. Birnam Wood is indeed coming to Dunsinane, fulfilling half of the witches’ prophecy. In the battle, Macbeth hews violently, but the English forces gradually overwhelm his army and castle and he realizes that he is doomed, Macbeth continues to fight until Macduff kills and beheads him.

    Failed Individuation in Shakespeare’s Macbeth

    macbeth
    macbeth

    Macbeth has not begun to deal with the adult developmental task of individuation. According to Jung, in the process of individuation “unconscious potentials are explored and reintegrated with the “Self”. The exploration of certain parts of the unconscious brings to consciousness unacknowledged ” missing pieces. Macbeth’s failure to individuate successfully is reflected by the distance between his rigid Persona and his real personality, and his inability to confront the shadow aspects of his psyche, and the complete rejection of his anima. Tellingly those developmental issues only seem able to get Macbeth’s attention through his hallucinations and visions. Jung said that “only through the adult development of individuation can the person become truly an ‘individual’ and not simply a carrier of unconscious images and other people’s projections”. This “carrier of unconscious images” and receptacle of “other people’s projections” is exactly how Shakespeare paints Macbeth: Macbeth is Duncan’s “O worthiest cousin” (I, iv, 17), the murderers’ “Highness,” “liege,” “lord” (III, I, 81, 102, and 131), and Malcolm’s “tyrant” (Iv, iii, 14). Throughout the play Macbeth’s identity is formed by Shakespeare’s other characters. The tragedy of Macbeth is that he has failed to explore his unconscious and discover and accept his true identity. Because he has not individuated, he can be molded and pushed into identities and actions that others project onto him. Macbeth is very conscious of his persona and of the positive reputation he has cultivated, and he enjoys thinking of himself in this way. According to Jung, the Persona (literally the mask) is the aspect of personality that adapts to the world to be accepted in society. Throughout the play Macbeth attempts to put on a “false face” (I, vii, 9 5) so that he can hide what his “false heart doth/know” (I, vii, 95-96). When he has plotted Banquo’s death and is preparing to make merry with his guests, Macbeth  believes that he can cover not only his conscious knowledge of his role in Banquo’s death from others but keep his unconscious feelings of fear, shock, and guilt at arranging a murder from himself. During dinner Macbeth has a hallucination. He sees the ghost of Banquo come to haunt him and denies his guilt: “Thou canst not say I did it. Never shake/ Thy gory locks at me” (III, iv, 61-62). Throughout the play Macbeth refuses to own his unconscious; he places supreme importance on appearances (Persona), his consciousness and refuses to deal with any desires and actions which challenge his idealized Ego.

    instinctive powerful, beast
    Shadow- instinctive powerful, beast

    His rejection and disregard of this “shadow” keep him ignorant of its motivational power and the gulf that develops between his persona and real personality. Jung described the shadow as “those aspects of the psyche that are rejected from consciousness by the ego (during sozialization in the first half of life), because they are inconsistent with one’s self-concept. Macbeth’s history of denying his shadow is detailed throughout the play. In Act I, after learning of Duncan’s intention of having Malcolm succeed to the throne, Macbeth rejects his ambitiously motivated ability to become a traitor. Jung says that as we show our persona to others and conceal our shadow from ourselves, “the shadow gets more and more ugly, and the split between persona and shadow … widens”. For Macbeth, this is true. After he kills Duncan, Macbeth refuses to believe that he could be a murderer – one although this ability to murder is present in Macbeth’s character. After his second meeting with the Weird Sisters, Macbeth resolves to kill Macduff’s family in the Thane of Fife’s absence Macbeth has progressed from ambitious regicide to familial mass murderer. Because  Macbeth has not confronted his shadow and haven’t taken the effort caused by introduction of the shadow to consciousness, Macbeth cannot follow an intrinsic moral compass. This allows him to commit his atrocities without having to justify them. Ironically, part of Macbeth’s anima is positive, but it is repressed because he believes it to contain negative qualities.

    anima
    anima

    According to Jung, men have “repressed feminine-typed qualities” (their anima) and women have “repressed masculine-typed qualities” (their animus). While this area of Macbeth seems cloudy, I believe that Macbeth cannot explore what Jung would call the inner feminine qualities of empathy and emotion because Lady Macbeth is constantly questioning his identity as a man, struggling herself to be a women and with her animus. Two passages support this theory. When Macbeth begins to vacillate between killing Duncan and maintaining his honorable reputation, Lady Macbeth chastises him for not being man enough to take what he wants (I, vii, 3 9-49). She also calls him to task for not being a man of his word (I, vii, 53-67). Lady Macbeth claims that she, a woman, is more manly than Macbeth. Macbeth is expressing fear and guilt, emotional inner controls, and Lady Macbeth makes fun at him. Later, when Macbeth is confronted with his hallucination of Banquo’s ghost, he expresses fear and revulsion at what he has done to Banquo through the ghost’s horrible appearance. Lady Macbeth tells him to stop acting like a hysterical woman and to live in reality. She even asks Macbeth, “Are you a man” (III, iv, 70). While Macbeth clearly rejects his “inner woman,” as shown by the ease with which he is manipulated by gender role identification (making him vulnerable to Lady Macbeth evilness), he is severely hampered in uncovering his anima by her disparaging of his male identity.

    Personal Layers
    Personal Layers

    Macbeth’s strict adherence to his inflated Ego a false Persona, his unwillingness to deal with his shadow. According to Jung rejecting anima have psychological consequences – sometimes the shadow and anima merge and overpower the consciousness (Ego); he has hallucinations.  Jung interpreted psychotic hallucinations and delusions as expressions of the collective unconscious archetypes, which can be interpreted as visions or a type of dream, manifesting their meaning from his personal unconscious. Act II’s floating dagger can be read as a symbol forcing its way into consciousness. Through his visions, Macbeth’s unconscious is trying to show him the issues he must deal with. One of the sadder aspects of the tragedy is that he is constantly dissuaded from looking at them. The moral conflict needed to mitigate his personal not to speak collective un consciousness  is not present.  This is why poor Macbeth (like many powerful men and women) is so far from the mark with his comments on life. They does not know enough about themself to allow anything but a shallow, two-dimensional interpretation of life, letting them be directed by passions unseen, greed and manipulative persons around them.

    Anima and Animus in Shakespeare’s Macbeth

    Lady Macbeth
    Lady Macbeth

    There appears to be some critical discord in connection to the classification of Lady Macbeth, whether she qualifies as an innocent, supportive wife, or, in Malcolm’s words, as a “fiend-like queen.” (Shakespeare V. ix. 35) However, Shakespeare’s text simply does not support the idea that the Lady Macbeth did not play a serious role in the murder of King Duncan and. The concept which seems to lie at the core of critical discussion in relation to Lady Macbeth, is gender. Lady Macbeth herself, makes the argument about gender in her famous speech, wherein she appeals to the powers of dark spirits to “unsex” her, and replace any feminine tendency in her with “direst cruelty” (Shakespeare I. v. 42-43). She wishes to take all that she perceives as weak and feminine in herself, and seeks to substitute it with an evil. Jung believed that all men and women were made up of masculine and feminine energies, the former being called the animus and the latter being called the anima and this unconscious selves of individuals can be used to understand Lady Macbeth’s actions. It can be argued, that Lady Macbeth’s vehement denial of her feminine self (or her anima) that causes her to manipulate her husband into committing the murder of Duncan, affected her relationship with her husband (unable to maintain it) and ultimately led to her insanity and death.

    Conclusion

     “Fair is foul, and foul is fair” : What the line points to is the play’s concern with the discrepancy between appearance and reality: that is, the difference between how someone seems and how someone really is. It is a central concern of Shakespeare’s, and obviously one that fits well with the medium of theatre, which relies on actors seeming to be something that they most definitely aren’t. This is one of the last lines in Act 1 Scene 1 when the witches are foreshadowing events to come in the play. With these words, they are predicting the evil that will cloud Macbeth’s judgments and that those judgments will appear to Macbeth as fair and just. This line also could refer to the witches believing that things some consider to be foul and ugly are just and beautiful to them because they embody evil.